Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
HomeWhat the Giants still need to get done and how they can do it

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

What the Giants still need to get done and how they can do it

The Giants have been pretty impressive in terms of keeping and acquiring talent.  I will break down the needed action by position

Quarterback-   It's pretty clear Eli Manning is the man and will be the man at least for all of this season.  The real question to be learned this year will be if last season's decline was due to age or was due to a lack of talent around him.    As for a backup, it seems the Giants could be content to ride with Josh Johnson and Geno Smith fighting it out as Eli's backup.  While the Giants drafting a QB wouldn't be a surprise, I think the quality of the draft class will make such a move unlikely. 

Running Back-   Paul Perkins and his 4.1 yd/carry average shows the team has their starting RB.  Behind him, they have fan/beat writer favorite Darkwa and 3rd down specialist Vereen.  With the RB draft class being plentiful one would expect to see the Giants draft a companion for Perkins.  However with many other draft needs/wants/could use drafting a RB isn't a sure thing.  Ellison fills the need if the Giants want to use a FB next season.

Wide Receiver-  If there is one area where the team has it's work completed it's at WR.  With OBJ, Marshal and Shepard as their top 3 and sophomores Lewis and King behind them, this position is set

Tight End-  The Giants have a top three of blocking TE Ellison, promising rookie TE Adams and Will Tye (who seemed to regress a bit from a promising rookie season) the team could stand pat.   I suspect the only way the team adds a TE is if the talent falling to them is too great to pass (with this TE class that's a real possibility).

Offensive Line-  This is perhaps the biggest enigma on the Giants roster.   You have 6 players who have been starters in Flowers, Hart, Fluker, Jerry, Richburg and Pugh.  Yet none of them seem to be ideally suited for the LT position.   Pugh may be best suited but the beat writers seem to think it's unlikely he is moved from LG to LT.  Pugh is solid at LG and Richburg is solid at center (and Brett Jones provides a nice backup C/G).   Now if Pugh was moved over to LT, Jones might be the best option at LG as he has the mobility the team looks for in their LG.  On the right side you have a mix and match.  Hart seems to be a solid backup RT but needs to get stronger if he wants to be a successful starter.  Pugh has been a starting RT and RG and if he loses a bit of weight could play RT pretty well.   Jerry has shown to be a starting caliber blocking RG but a less than ideal run blocking RG.  To add to the mix is Mike Bowie who if healthy could be another competitor for a backup role and maybe even a starting role.   If the team were to draft an offense lineman, I would think it would be in the first round with Bolles or Ramcyzk or maybe round two with Dion Dawkins.  Those are the only 3 I could see being a guy who could start at LT and allow the line to really improve.  Of course, if the team moved Pugh to LT then a mobile LG could be a target (Lamp would be a nice choice).

Now we will move on to the defense.  Oddly enough despite all that was spent and the Giants holding on to JPP this unit still has some significant work to do.

Defensive Line-  With all the money spent on the line you have 3 top starters in JPP and Vernon on the ends and Snacks manning the 1 tech.   The biggest starter whole is at 3 tech.   Now I have looked over the remaining 3 tech DTs and I wouldn't rule out the team signing on an older veteran and I wouldn't even be shocked if they re-sign Hankins on an inexpensive prove it deal.   Still, regardless of a veteran addition the team would be well served to consider drafting a 3 tech DT in rounds 2-4.  There are no really impressive ones to target in round 1 but I could see guys worthy of being drafted in the next 3 rounds.   By drafting one this year they could be developed and take over from the older vet or Hankins next season.   For the record I am thinking Bromley isn't the answer.   I could also see the Giants drafting another pass rusher a talented one falls to them.  The amount of snaps Vernon and JPP are taking is unsustainable so having a guy that give them a break would be a major asset (either that or they have to hope O-Diggy surprises or Romeo continues to improve)

Linebacker-  This is another challenging situation.  As of this writing, the team hasn't secured a proper coverage LB.   Last year that role was filled by Robinson.  I could see the Giants drafting a LB in the first or second round with the coverage skills needed.  It's also possible that Reese will draft a LB with pass rushing skills as it appeared he wanted to do last year with Floyd.  The team does have a strong SAM starter in Kennard and team captain and serviceable Will backer in Casillas.  The assumption is Goodson will be the pencilled in starter at MIKE.   With his concussion history, I think the team needs a strong backup MLB.  That could come from the draft or the team could sign a veteran as there are still a few available.

Defensive Backs-  The Giants will most likely stand pat at Safety.  They have Collins and Thompson as their starters.  Behind them is Adams (who did a good job when pressed into a starting role as a rookie) and they have Nat Berhe and even a former starter in Rahim Moore who might succeed in getting his career back on track.   At CB the team is set with their top 3.  What's missing is the guys after those top 3.   I would expect that the Giants will draft a CB in the middle rounds as this draft is chock full of good CBs.  He would provide needed depth and would be the eventual replacement for DRC when the team finally parts ways with him.  I also wouldn't rule out the team bringing back veteran CB Coty Sensabaugh who played well with the Giants last year


Special teams-  The team is pretty set at punter and long snapper with Wing and DeOssie.   I sort of expect the Giants to draft one of the roughly 3 kickers worthy of draft consideration or at least sign one after the draft.  They do have Aldrick Rosas who has a strong leg and might do well under the Giants coaching.  The other position that might be nice to address in the draft or after the draft is a proper return specials as Dwayne Harris has been quite dissappointing in that role. 

 

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

That was from a preseason game in 2000, Rich. Here's a link: https://mobile.nytimes.com/2000/08/13/sports/pro-football-giants-see-the-good-after-loss-to-jaguars.html?referer=https://www.google.com/Jack Golden actually made the team as a UDFA after tha...
Read more...
Some things I want to add:-For some reason, the "2015 offensive passing stats were inflated by playing from behind" fallacy just won't die. The Giants played from behind in 3 out of 16 games that season. The narrative was the offense, behind Eli's str...
Read more...
Quote from: Vette on Today at 12:27:44 PMAnd they lost 2 of those 3 games. Eli kept the Giants in the game in the shootout against Brees and the Saints and the OBJ meltdown in the Panther's game. The games they lost, th...
Read more...
Quote from: Bob In PA on Today at 10:54:37 AMBy suggesting that PFF re-do its system for ranking QB's I wasn't necessarily suggesting replacing it with a system that makes Eli look better.    Bobhaha I ...
Read more...
So our offensive genius still hasn't fixed the running game and has imposed an offense that doesn't really fit our 2-time SB MVP and possible HOF candidate*.  Link an average defense to our 2016 offfense and our record could have easily been reversed, ...
Read more...

Inside Football News

The New York Giants will open their annual summer training... The post Giants Release Public Training Camp Schedule appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
How Odell Beckham Jr can go from being one of... The post 2017 Training Camp Preview: WR Odell Beckham Jr appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
Patricia Traina (Inside Football) and Ed Valentine (Big Blue View)... The post New York Giants “Big Blue Chat” Podcast No. 122: Spring Football Wrapup appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

Examining whether Darrelle Revis or Alterraun Verner are realistic targets to enhance the Giants' cornerback depth. Plus: Will Odell Beckham Jr. return more punts in 2017? And will Ben McAdoo's hair get the Giants to the Super Bowl?
Read more...
Giants cornerbacks coach Tim Walton was in St. Louis with Jenkins in 2013.
Read more...
An update on the destinations of Giants free agents, including Johnathan Hankins, Victor Cruz and Ryan Nassib.
Read more...

Big Blue View

Second-year wide receiver faces stiff competition for his spot When Roger Lewis Jr. talked to Big Blue View’s Chris Pflum shortly after the end of the 2016 season he called it “a blessing” to catch passes from Eli Manning, especially having grown up rooting for Manning and the New York Giants. Question is, will Lewis get to do that again in 2017? Let’s take a closer look at the second-year wide receiver as we continue our player-by-player profiles of the Giants’ 90-man roster. 2016 Season In Review Lewis made the Giants’ roster as an undrafted free agent out of Bowling Green....
Read more...
UDFA a long-shot to make it with the Giants At 6-foot-3, 220 pounds, Jerome Lane is a big-bodied wide receiver who came to the New York Giants late, signing as an undrafted rookie free agent on June 2. Can Lane make up for lost time and earn a spot with the Giants, at least as a member of the practice squad? Let’s take a closer look as we continue our player-by-player profiles of the Giants’ 90-man roster. 2016 Season In Review In 12 games, Lane caught 62 passes for 1,018 yards, an average of 16.4 yards per catch. He scored six...
Read more...
Go to top