Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
HomeAn Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

I found this outsider's take from Fantasy Alarm rather interesting even if I don't agree:
 

Quote
Despite finishing 11-5 last season, the Giants have some serious issues throughout their roster. They basically got by with unconscious play from their high-priced defense and one-to-two game breaking plays per game from Odell Beckham Jr. While impressive is an understatement for their 2016 accomplishments considering what they were working with, you can’t with a straight face argue that this is a repeatable recipe for success going forward. Serious changes are needed throughout this Giants roster…
 



First here are some of the reasons I think that this author could be right:

1)  The Giants had a relatively easy schedule in terms of how the schedule fell when the Bye was and the strength of the teams played.  Not sure this can be repeated

2)  The Giants were relatively healthy although they did have key injuries to Will Johnson (that cost them their FB), Darian Thompson (who seemed to prevent the other team's big plays), JPP (especially in the critical GB game) and assorted issues with offensive linemen.    Still they had been healthier than in previous seasons  

3)  The Giants won almost all the close games.  Not sure that's an easy feat to repeat.

Now there are reasons to think the team will do as well if not better than last season

1)  Ben McAdoo is no longer a rookie head coach.  No doubt Ben has learned important lessons after his first year ever being a head coach

2)  The coaching staff is maintaining its continuity.  This is very important in terms of players knowing their assignments to drafting and acquiring talent.  Continuity is a key building block of success

3)  The team is almost completely intact.  Even if Hankins walks (there are still other FAs or draft options), this team will have another year playing together and knowing the system.

4)  The Giants had a championship caliber defense last year.  While there is not press A to continue, there is no reason to think the defense will not continue to excel.  Considering how many new defensive starters there were last season, you would think the continuity of players in the system will only make things better.

5)  The Giants have already fixed to critical offensive holes in signing a big WRs (something lacking last year) in Marshall and filling the hole at FB and blocking TE in Ellison

6)  The team does not have father time hitting them at many positions.  With the possible exception of Eli and maybe DRC there is no reason to believe the team will be seeing much in the way of age-related decline

7)  There are a couple of 2nd-year players who should be reasonably expected to improve.  The physically talented Eli Apple has a year under his belt to help shed the "raw" label.  Darian Thompson's return at FS should help the defense cut down on big plays given up.  Romeo Okwara should get better with seasoning.   I think it's not unreasonable to expect Adams and Goodson to contribute more this upcoming season.  Finally Perkins and his 4.0 yards a carry should have a much bigger role this season.

8)  The team already looks like it's a contender and that's before they add talent via the draft

For those interested in article I drew the quote from

http://www.fantasyalarm.com/articles/dmurtha/39059/2017-divisional-draft-needs-nfc-east/

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

My side of the fence was Giants, Rangers, Yankees, & Knicks.On the other side of the fence was the Jets, Islanders, Mets & Nets.
Read more...
Shaw's resume says he worked for Bill Walsh at Stanford.  Got to like that.
Read more...
Great post Rich. I just want you to know that you, going out and finding great links every day to post, is why this site is my favorite and first place I check for Giants analysis and info.You are appreciated 
Read more...
I think David Shaw is a good college head football coach, however, it is important to remember that it was Jim Harbaugh who resurrected the Stanford program.  David Shaw has continued the excellent legacy at Stanford that Harbaugh started.  I think he ...
Read more...
While the Chiefs aren't a dominant run defense, it was pretty nice to see the Giants oline look like a professional football unit!
Read more...

Inside Football News

For New York Giants left tackle Ereck Flowers, Week 2... The post Ereck Flowers is Starting to Bloom appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
If only because nothing else has made sense in this... The post Report Card | New York Giants 12, Kansas City Chiefs 9 appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
The New York Giants appear to be bracing for their ... The post Injury Report | D.J. Fluker Could Miss Thursday’s Game with Toe Injury appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

The wide receiver's status for Thursday's game is unknown.
Read more...
From a blowout Steelers win over the Titans on Thursday Night Football, to a surprise Giants win over the Chiefs, to a decisive Eagles win over the Cowboys on Sunday Night Football, to the Atlanta Falcons taking care of business on Monday Night Football, the NFL gave us no shortage of talking points this week.
Read more...
Lawrence Taylor and Joe Thiesmann were reunited thanks to NBC's Thanksgiving games.
Read more...

Big Blue View

Let’s look at the full injury list After missing Sunday’s game against the Kansas City Chiefs with a migraine headache, New York Giants wide receiver Sterling Shepard does not appear to be improving. Coach Ben McAdoo said Tuesday that Shepard is “not feeling well” and the medical staff is “looking at all the possibilities.” McAdoo said the second-year wide receiver is not in the concussion protocol. It appears, however, that Shepard is going to miss Thursday’s game against the Washington Redskins. D.J. Fluker is apparently in a walking boot and told media at the Giants’ practice facility that he is...
Read more...
Washington had 22 players on Monday injury list If you think the New York Giants’ injury situation heading into Thursday night’s game is bad, you’re right, it is. It is nothing, though, compared to what the Washington Redskins are facing. With 22 players on Monday’s injury report, Redskins coach Jay Gruden admitted Tuesday his team can’t really even practice. “It’s quite the challenge,” Gruden told New York media via conference call. “We’re only going to do walk-throughs this week. We’re pretty dinged up and we don’t have really enough guys to get 11 on 11 right now for look...
Read more...
Go to top