Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
HomeAn Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

I found this outsider's take from Fantasy Alarm rather interesting even if I don't agree:
 

Quote
Despite finishing 11-5 last season, the Giants have some serious issues throughout their roster. They basically got by with unconscious play from their high-priced defense and one-to-two game breaking plays per game from Odell Beckham Jr. While impressive is an understatement for their 2016 accomplishments considering what they were working with, you can’t with a straight face argue that this is a repeatable recipe for success going forward. Serious changes are needed throughout this Giants roster…
 



First here are some of the reasons I think that this author could be right:

1)  The Giants had a relatively easy schedule in terms of how the schedule fell when the Bye was and the strength of the teams played.  Not sure this can be repeated

2)  The Giants were relatively healthy although they did have key injuries to Will Johnson (that cost them their FB), Darian Thompson (who seemed to prevent the other team's big plays), JPP (especially in the critical GB game) and assorted issues with offensive linemen.    Still they had been healthier than in previous seasons  

3)  The Giants won almost all the close games.  Not sure that's an easy feat to repeat.

Now there are reasons to think the team will do as well if not better than last season

1)  Ben McAdoo is no longer a rookie head coach.  No doubt Ben has learned important lessons after his first year ever being a head coach

2)  The coaching staff is maintaining its continuity.  This is very important in terms of players knowing their assignments to drafting and acquiring talent.  Continuity is a key building block of success

3)  The team is almost completely intact.  Even if Hankins walks (there are still other FAs or draft options), this team will have another year playing together and knowing the system.

4)  The Giants had a championship caliber defense last year.  While there is not press A to continue, there is no reason to think the defense will not continue to excel.  Considering how many new defensive starters there were last season, you would think the continuity of players in the system will only make things better.

5)  The Giants have already fixed to critical offensive holes in signing a big WRs (something lacking last year) in Marshall and filling the hole at FB and blocking TE in Ellison

6)  The team does not have father time hitting them at many positions.  With the possible exception of Eli and maybe DRC there is no reason to believe the team will be seeing much in the way of age-related decline

7)  There are a couple of 2nd-year players who should be reasonably expected to improve.  The physically talented Eli Apple has a year under his belt to help shed the "raw" label.  Darian Thompson's return at FS should help the defense cut down on big plays given up.  Romeo Okwara should get better with seasoning.   I think it's not unreasonable to expect Adams and Goodson to contribute more this upcoming season.  Finally Perkins and his 4.0 yards a carry should have a much bigger role this season.

8)  The team already looks like it's a contender and that's before they add talent via the draft

For those interested in article I drew the quote from

http://www.fantasyalarm.com/articles/dmurtha/39059/2017-divisional-draft-needs-nfc-east/

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

1. Cleveland - QB Mitchell Trubisky, North Carolina 2. San Francisco - DE Myles Garrett, Texas A&M 3. Chicago - CB Marshawn Lattimore, Ohio State 4. Jacksonville - RB Leonard Fournette, LSU 5. Tennessee - S Jamal Adams, LSU6. NY Jets - T Cam Robin...
Read more...
ANYONE who claims the Giants lost the Green Bay game because of Odell, isn't being honest about that game and is letting their bias show. I broke down the stats, repeatedly, so I won't bore people by doing it again. It's all there on NFL.com for anyone...
Read more...
Quote from: gregf on April 26, 2017, 07:36:49 PMGreat stuff!  Thanks so much!  Pat's response about not putting a rookie at OT was a fresh perspective. I really like her reasons why a pass catching TE will help the offense. S...
Read more...
The first four rounds have plenty of talent to find starters and role players of either solid depth or special teams. When a team picks players like Damontre Moore and doesn't see he's a head case, Ryan Nassib and trades up for a clip Board Holder, Rue...
Read more...

Inside Football News

Patricia Traina (Inside Football) and Ed Valentine (Big Blue View)...
Read more...
Let’s do a little number crunching and break down what...
Read more...
Let’s take a final temperature check before the NFL draft....
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

Running down the Giants' 2017 NFL Draft selections, from No. 23 to No. 241.
Read more...
The 2017 NFL Draft will be held in Philadelphia from April 27 to April 30, 2017, with the first round on Thursday, April 27, the second and third rounds on Friday, April 28, and the fourth through seventh rounds on Saturday, April 29. The Cleveland Browns hold the first pick of the draft.
Read more...
The 2017 NFL Draft will be held in Philadelphia from April 27 to April 30, 2017, with the first round on Thursday, April 27, the second and third rounds on Friday, April 28, and the fourth through seventh rounds on Saturday, April 29.
Read more...

Big Blue View

Increasingly, speculation has Bolles as Giants top target The “Garett Bolles as a primary target for the New York Giants in the 2017 NFL Draft” drumbeat continued to grow louder on Wednesday night. We wrote earlier on Wednesday about how several sources were linking Bolles and the Giants. NFL Network analyst Mike Mayock followed up Wednesday night by mocking Bolles to the Giants. That begs a question — if all of this Bolles speculation is on target, would the Giants actually consider trading up to select the Utah offensive tackle? NFL insider Adam Schefter reported Wednesday that the Tampa Bay...
Read more...
Everything you need to know settle in and watch Round 1 The 2017 NFL Draft is finally here. After months of speculation, mock drafts, rumors — and arguing — we finally find out on Thursday night what the New York Giants will do in Round 1. Will they select a linebacker for the first time since 1984? Will they trade up, ostensibly for an offensive tackle? Will they trade down? Will select a tight end? Will they do something completely unexpected? Day 2 of the draft will feature Harry Carson (Round 2) and Jessie Armstead (Round 3) announcing the Giants...
Read more...
Go to top