Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
HomeWhich positions should the Giants draft?

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

Which positions should the Giants draft?

I have been working out who might be available where and how they fit into the Giants scheme:

OFFENSE

Quarterback-  Eli Manning is 36 years old and the team has started discussing finding his successor.   Eli had a down year last season, but a good deal of his issues could be attributed to a weak offensive line, a lack of a proper running game and a stable of relatively short WRs.   The team seems to have fixed some of the issues.   The team could seriously consider someone like Mahomes in round one (assuming he lasts and there isn't an early QB frenzy).  The team really doesn't have the juice to move up significantly should there be a run (their 3 round pick would only buy them 4 spots).  They could "settle" on lower round QBs.   Jaws thinks that Pitt's Nathan Peterman would be a good fit for the Giants and should be available in the 3rd round.  There is also Miami's Brad Kaaya who should be around rnds 4 or 5 and while I was less than impressed does have good traits for Ben's offense.   If things don't work out in terms of the way the draft plays out, I see the team staying pat as Geno Smith gives them some flexibility.

Wide Receiver-  I would be shocked if the team drafts one as they are pretty settled at this position with the signing of Marshall

Tight End-  The team now has a good blocker in Ellison, a TE they believe is a developmental guy in Adams and a guy who regressed (and doesn't block) in Tye.   I see the team having room for a good TE.    Njoku would be a nice option in round 1 (should he fall).   Gerald Everett would be an option in the 2nd round.  Bucky Hodges an option in the 3rd and Toledo's Michael Roberts a 4th round possibility.    The team could stand pat at TE if need be (if the draft doesnt' fall or they need the picks for other players)

Running Back-  This seems like a stronger but not desperate need.  I think Paul Perkins will be the team's main back and Vereen offers a third down, alternate.   There is also Darkwa and the newly signed Shaun Draughn.   If the team does feel the need, I know many are high on Christian McCaffrey should he fall to the team in the first round.  I am not seeing this though.   If he were still there in the 2nd, I would have to think that Joe Mixon would be tempting for the team (but they may pass).  Kareem Hunt would be an interesting option in the 3rd round and Chris Carson a 4th round possibility.   I think odds are the Giants will draft a running back from the guys I mentoned, but it's far from a sure thing.

Offensive Tackle-  While I have been one calling for a new LT, I can't help but shake the feeling the Giants will stand pat with Flowers at LT (I think the Fluker comments along with the comments of the ownership and coach is why).   If the Giants want a plug and play LT I suspect that the options in round one (the only round I see potential starters) is Ramczyk, Bolles and Dawkins.  It's possible at least the first 2 will be gone when the Giants draft and I am not sure how they feel about Dawkins.  After that you are looking at developmental type prospects such as Taylor Morton (RT only) in the 2nd, Roderick Johnson in the 2nd, Jermaine Eluemunor in the 3rd, Julie'n Davenport in the 3rd or Antonio Garcia in the 3rd (maybe the 2nd).  I see the Giants drafting a starter in round one or at least one of the projects I mentioned.  

Offensive Guard/Center- At first glance, this position would seem to be solid with Richburg at center Pugh, Jerry and Hart/Fluker (the loser of the RT competition) and Jones the backup guard/center.  However, Pugh and Richburg are both free agents next year and the team's cap will be tighter next season.  So there could be room to draft a guard or a guard who can double at center.   There are plenty of interesting prospects to pick from.  In the 2nd round, you have Dan Feeney and Taylor Morton (G/RT).   In round 3 you have Nico Siragusa and Dorian Johnson.  In the 4th you have Isaac Asiata and Damien Mama.  I see a guard being drafted as a possibility, but not a really good one.


DEFENSE

Defensive End-  With JPP signed the odds seem unlikely that the Giants will take another DE in Round one or maybe two.  Now JPP and Vernon were overworked last season.   The real question is if one of the trio of Wynn (tendered), Odiggy or Romeo O.  Romeo is still developing and should be better this upcoming season.  Odiggy has been hampere by injury and there is little to believe he will be able to stay healthy and Wynn is a run stopper who regressed in his sophomore season.   Daeshon Hall in the 2nd round and Hunter Dimick in the 3rd round looked to be interesting prospects.

Defensive Tech-  This will be tricky until the Hankins situation is resolved.  If Hankins signs the Giants long term offer there will be no in interest in a 3 tech DT.  If he signs a one year deal or the Giants are forced to sign an older vet than there could be players of interest in the draft.  Chris Wormley DE/DT would be high on my list if he makes it to the 2nd round spot (might even trade up).  Montravius Adams is another option in round 2.  In round 3 options would include (or might include) Larry Ogunjobi or  Eddie Vanderdoes.  In round 4 you would have to consider Jarron Jones and round 5 Dalvin Tomlinson.   I see little need for the Giants to draft a 1 tech with Snacks and Thomas.    Bromley remains the backup 3 tech.

Linebacker-  The team could skip this position with the core of Kennard (who is a free agent after this season), Casillas, Goodson and Robinson.   That group can get the job done.  The team does have some backups as well in Herzlich, Thomas, Skinner and Pinkins.   If the team were to draft anyone I think it would be a MLB or a hybrid pass rusher LB to play a sort of Kiwi role.  Zach Cunningham would be the sort of similar to Kiwi type to draft in round 1.  Ruben Foster would be a huge impact MLB who may drop to the Giants at 23.  Beyond that I see little to interest the team other than maybe Richie Brown a MLB who would be a nice 5th round pick.

Cornerback-  You would think with Jenkins, Apple and DRC there would be little need to draft a CB.  However this draft class is full of CB prospects and the team needs another solid option to eventually replace DRC (who I see the team parting ways with after this season).  I see CB as likely anywhere after round one.   In the second round Fabian Moreau would be a nice choice.  Round 3 you would have option like Shaquill Griffin.  5th round would offer Brian Allen and Brendan Langley.  There are others but I stayed away from the zone type CBs as the Giants play more M2M.

Safety-   The team seems pretty solid at this position with Collins and Thompson set to start.  Adams is a nice backup along with Berhe.  There is also veteran Rahim Moore trying to make a comeback.   If the team drafts a S, I would expect it to be very late in the draft.  The team also has former draft pick Mykkelle Thompson. 

 

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

I think PFF is becoming more pathetic by the day. The owners of that site are making Bernie Madoff prouder by the day.
Read more...
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 10:59:12 AMLol!  Dale....   and you take that love for Eli to a whole new level  Well at least you are learning from me and taking your mancrush on Davis Webb to an ...
Read more...
Is Munson quicker than Herzlich?
Read more...
Quote from: Echunks on Today at 12:34:27 PMI agree his pad level and hand placement are also issues, but the fact that he gives ground so easily in pass protection tells you that his quickness and agility are also real ...
Read more...
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 10:46:29 AMI will say this, Flower's issues are not speed related.  His two issues are his pad levels (he needs to have much better knee bend so that he can gain more power and lever...
Read more...

Inside Football News

New York Giants linebacker J.T. Thomas, activated off the PUP... The post Report: LB J.T. Thomas Takes a Paycut appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
Patricia Traina (Inside Football) and Ed Valentine (Big Blue View)... The post Big Blue Chat Podcast No. 126: New York Giants Training Camp Reflections appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
The 2017 New York Giants training camp is officially in... The post New York Giants 2017 Training Camp Rewind appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

J.T. Thomas has taken a pay cut and put himself on even footing for a chance to win a Giants roster spot.
Read more...
Ex-Redskins general manager Scot McCloughan believes unemployed quarterback Colin Kaepernick is good enough to start.
Read more...
The star wide receivers are saying all the right things in the preseason.
Read more...

Big Blue View

The linebacker takes less to stay with the team New York Giants linebacker J.T. Thomas made his return from the PUP list this week, and Field Yates of ESPN is reporting that he has accepted a 2.2mil pay cut to remain on the team. Sources: Giants LB JT Thomas has taken a pay cut from $2.975M to $775K, with a roster bonus of $20k and $400k if he plays 70% of the snaps.— Field Yates (@FieldYates) August 17, 2017 Thomas was on the physically unable to perform list throughout the offseason and training camp while he worked his way...
Read more...
Defensive lineman picks up prominent endorsement Jordan Williams, an undrafted free agent out of Tennessee on his third franchise in three NFL seasons, would seem like a long shot to make the New York Giants’ roster as part of a talented, deep defensive line. Williams, though, has begun to make himself noticed as the Giants prep for the 2017 season. And he has picked up the endorsement of linebacker Jonathan Casillas, the team’s defensive captain in 2016. “I think the way he’s playing right now he could be a Giant for sure. I would take him on my team if...
Read more...
Go to top