Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
HomeWhat Kind of Coach is Ben McAdoo?

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

What Kind of Coach is Ben McAdoo?

One of my favorite movie quotes comes from the movie, “The Breakfast Club.”  “You see us as you want to see us - in the simplest terms, in the most convenient definitions. But what we found out is that each one of us is a brain and an athlete and a basket case and a princess and a criminal.  Does that answer your question? Sincerely yours, the Breakfast Club.”  I believe that is what vexes people when it comes to coach Ben McAdoo.  He doesn’t fit the most convenient definition.

It would be comforting to many if Ben McAdoo fit one of the usual definitions for a head coach.   The brilliant Xs and Os coaches like Bill Belichick, the player-friendly coach like Buddy Ryan, the Disciplinarian like Tom Coughlin or a great motivator like Bill Parcells.  When you try to apply one of these usual categories to Ben McAdoo, they don’t seem to fit any more than the suit he wore for his initial press conference.

Ben’s Xs and Os style is similar to his first mentor Mike McCarthy.  It’s a basic style of play calling that challenges the receivers to beat their one on one matchups.   It’s been proven successful in Green Bay and with the Giants.  Ben’s first two offenses finished 10th and 8th, in his first two seasons. The drop to the 25th spot this past season has made many question Ben’s abilities as an offensive coach.   Some have questioned if he should be calling his own plays as his mentor in Green Bay does.  Some wonder if it was the result of Ben losing the two fullbacks he brought into camp and the resulting reduction in the variety of formations.  Others may point to the fact that the teams starting tight end, Larry Donnell, starting running back, Rashad Jennings and number two wide receiver, Victor Cruz are all currently unemployed.   One could also point out that similar comments were made just the prior season about Steve Spagnolo and his defense.  Still, with such a basic style of offense, it’s hard to say Xs and Os are Ben’s calling cards.

Ben might better fit into the category of the player-friendly coach.  His millennial-friendly style and unassuming presence would seem to fit the profile.   His players all seem to speak of him highly, and with great respect, so it might be a label that could fit.   His public challenges to his starting quarterback, Eli Manning, would tend to suggest that he doesn’t exactly fit the mold of the most player friendly of coaches.  His team played with more discipline than one usually sees under a player-friendly coach.

While Ben still has the clocks set to “Coughlin time,” he hardly fits the profile of a hard-nosed disciplinarian.   Sure his teams tend to play with good discipline and poise under pressure, but where are the blowups on the sidelines?  Where are the players being suspended for parts of games?   Where are the long sets of rules the players need to follow?   While it appears Ben is firm, he doesn’t show the hallmarks of a classic disciplinarian.

The final label that some coaches get is the master motivator.    While Ben’s team certainly played hard last season, there are no stories of brilliant mind games that usually mark that type.  Plus the way Ben is economical in his words just doesn’t paint the picture of a guy who gets teams fired up with brilliant speeches.

People can’t deny that Ben turned around a franchise that hadn’t seen a winning season since “The Avengers” was the highest-grossing movie of the year, 2012.   More than a few people seem unwilling to give Coach McAdoo the credit a head coach usually receives for such achievements.   While it’s not unreasonable to suggest the addition of three big ticket free agents (Snacks, Vernon and Jenkins) helped the team’s fortunes it doesn’t fully explain an 11-5 record and the team’s first playoff birth since 2011.  Without a label as way to understand how Ben created this winning team many simply decline to give him credit.

So what kind of coach is the man who looks and carries himself more like a gym teacher than what people imagine when they think of a head coach of an NFL franchise?  The answer to that question is complex.   To start with, Ben is a more intelligent than many people give him credit.  It may be Ben’s unassuming ways, but it belies that he graduated summa cum laude from Indiana University of Pennsylvania with a degree in health and physical education or that he got a master’s degree in kinesiology in just nine months from Michigan State University.  Ben was the sort of intelligent man that had plans of becoming a lawyer.  It was when he learned just how much passion he had for the game of football that he changed his plans and pursued a career in coaching. 

Perhaps Ben’s biggest strength as a coach is his ability to teach.  Ben prides himself on his abilities as a teacher and feels it’s a very important aspect of coaching.  This ability to teach and develop young players might explain why players like OBJ, Shepard and even a raw tight end from little Stony Brook University, Will Tye were able to contribute so much as rookies.  The ability to teach and develop young players is nearly as important as drafting and signing the right players.  It’s probably more than just a coincidence that the team got so much contribution from their rookie draft and undrafted free agent class last season.  It’s more than likely a product of effective teaching and development.

As newly signed quarterback Geno Smith proclaimed, Ben Mcadoo is also a progressive coach.  You see that ability to push the envelope in things like the change of the traditional day off.  Ben changed that to allow players to better rest and recover from games.    You could see it in his adjustment to the training camp practice schedule or the addition of recovery Fridays.  Ben shortened the length of team meetings and increased the numbers because he had seen studies that indicate that millennials are best able to absorb knowledge in shorter doses.  One might attribute the team’s better health to Ben’s kinesiology background and wholehearted endorsement of cutting edge athletic training techniques.

Reports from players show he does have a bit of the player’s coach in him.  You can see it in practice as he is calling out guys names or recognizing a birthday.   Reports from players say he will joke about himself and they all look forward to the first slide of his meetings which are always something humorous.  For all his friendliness one look at last year’s training camp shows he is not soft on his players.   If anything, Ben’s camps looked to be more physically demanding that even Tom Coughlin’s.  There was little down time as the players seemed to be constantly moving and always busy.

So for a rookie head coach who never was the head coach of any football team before taking over the Giants, his performance was very impressive.  Sure there were a few notable bumps in the road, such as the radio incident and the infamous trip to Florida by the wide receiving corp.  When you consider what he accomplished in just one year, perhaps the best label, for those that need one, is WINNER.   

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

Kiwi would have been even more productive had he not been jerked around with a failed position change. Gerris Wilkerson could do everything at the linebacker position except stay on the field. The guy was such a tease, he'd stay healthy and play well f...
Read more...
To your point files, effective strategy with the right OL components. I do remember a time when pushing the ball carrier from behind was illegal though. Don't know what happened to that rule?Agree with the WCO  overview. If the receiver can't make th...
Read more...
You gotta admit the "quantity over quality" trade out types are pretty resilient as only once in recent memory can I recall the Giants trading out of their 1st Round pick. That was in '06 when they swapped their first-round pick (25) for Pittsburgh's (...
Read more...
My issue with Spags is his demeanor.. he is a nice guy, possibly too nice.. he lost control of his guys... that is a no no for a coach
Read more...
At his first press conference, Gettleman is asked about the next HC. Without hesitation, he says defense wins championships. Cue forward a few weeks, the Giants hire another QB guru as the head coach. (And the 7th offensive coach out of the last eigh...
Read more...

Inside Football News

The New York Giants offense could have a very different... The post A Look at Some Potential Key Assistant Coaching Decisions appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
The New York Giants are reportedly planning to offer their... The post REPORT: Giants Set to Name Pat Shurmur as Its Next Head Coach appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...
While the NFL put on a heck of a show... The post Updating the Giants Head Coaching Search appeared first on Inside Football.
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

Odell Beckham Jr. is excited to work with Vikings OC Pat Shurmur as Giants coach. A Pro Football Hall of Famer also was quick to praise the expected hire.
Read more...
Will Pat Shurmur retain Giants defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo? Not based ont eh results, but their relationship is telling.
Read more...
Apple no longer speaks to his stepfather, who was a major influence in his career.
Read more...

Big Blue View

Solari is the sixth Ben McAdoo assistant to accept a job elsewhere Former New York Giants assistant coach Mike Solari has accepted a job with the Seattle Seahawks to be the team’s next offensive line coach, the same position he held with the Giants. Solari spent two seasons as the Giants offensive line coach under former head coach Ben McAdoo. Solari will take the place of Tom Cable, who was the team’s offensive line coach for the past seven seasons. One more assistant coach about to return to Seattle: Mike Solari will once again be the team’s...
Read more...
He doesn’t officially have the job, but here are some questions we need answered when he gets it Pat Shurmur is not head coach of the New York Giants yet. NFL rules don’t allow coaches who’s teams are still playing to sign with other teams, and Shurmur’s Minnesota Vikings play the Philadelphia Eagles in the NFC Championship Game this weekend. Shurmur is “likely to be” or “expected to be” or “reportedly will be” Giants’ coach once the Vikings are done playing. Put it whatever way you want. Unless something crazy happens Shurmur is going to be the Giants’ next...
Read more...
Go to top