Home of the Best Informed
Giants Fans
Home

Giants Football by Big Blue Huddle

An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

I found this outsider's take from Fantasy Alarm rather interesting even if I don't agree:
 

Quote
Despite finishing 11-5 last season, the Giants have some serious issues throughout their roster. They basically got by with unconscious play from their high-priced defense and one-to-two game breaking plays per game from Odell Beckham Jr. While impressive is an understatement for their 2016 accomplishments considering what they were working with, you can’t with a straight face argue that this is a repeatable recipe for success going forward. Serious changes are needed throughout this Giants roster…
 



First here are some of the reasons I think that this author could be right:

1)  The Giants had a relatively easy schedule in terms of how the schedule fell when the Bye was and the strength of the teams played.  Not sure this can be repeated

Read more: An Outsider's perspective on the Giants roster, and why I don't agree

I like what Jerry Reese is doing in this free agency period

I am a firm believer in the best way to work the draft is to go into the draft with no pressing needs.   Well the way Jerry is working the draft in terms of retaining players and adding players he is effectively eliminating any sort of pressing need (I am anticipating Hankins or a replacement to be signed shortly).   That means the team will be able to literally go best athlete available in the early rounds.   Now the team does ideally need to pick up a CB and a RB in later rounds but I classify that more as you need room for the new draft picks to contribute rather than a pressing need that forces a team to reach for need.

Now consider the positions

QB-  The team could draft one in any round including round 1 if they feel they can get their next franchise QB.

Read more: I like what Jerry Reese is doing in this free agency period

What the Giants still need to get done and how they can do it

The Giants have been pretty impressive in terms of keeping and acquiring talent.  I will break down the needed action by position

Quarterback-   It's pretty clear Eli Manning is the man and will be the man at least for all of this season.  The real question to be learned this year will be if last season's decline was due to age or was due to a lack of talent around him.    As for a backup, it seems the Giants could be content to ride with Josh Johnson and Geno Smith fighting it out as Eli's backup.  While the Giants drafting a QB wouldn't be a surprise, I think the quality of the draft class will make such a move unlikely. 

Running Back-   Paul Perkins and his 4.1 yd/carry average shows the team has their starting RB.  Behind him, they have fan/beat writer favorite Darkwa and 3rd down specialist Vereen.  With the RB draft class being plentiful one would expect to see the Giants draft a companion for Perkins.  However with many other draft needs/wants/could use drafting a RB isn't a sure thing.  Ellison fills the need if the Giants want to use a FB next season.

Wide Receiver-  If there is one area where the team has it's work completed it's at WR.  With OBJ, Marshal and Shepard as their top 3 and sophomores Lewis and King behind them, this position is set

Tight End-  The Giants have a top three of blocking TE Ellison, promising rookie TE Adams and Will Tye (who seemed to regress a bit from a promising rookie season) the team could stand pat.   I suspect the only way the team adds a TE is if the talent falling to them is too great to pass (with this TE class that's a real possibility).

Read more: What the Giants still need to get done and how they can do it
  •  Start 
  •  Prev 
  •  1  2  3  4 
  •  Next 
  •  End 

Page 1 of 4

Giants News Tweets

Big Blue Huddle MB

Quote from: Vette on Today at 01:14:25 PMGreen Bay and Aaron Rodgers provided the blueprint to defeat the Giants defense and somewhat exposed them. Granted they had key injuries but they need to get to the QB this year ...
Read more...
Quote from: weeze on Today at 04:20:37 PMthink I rather watch a rerun of a "bad" WD episode then a "good" syndicated prime time show anytime!I think I'd agree Weeze. But I'm not sure if that says more about Th...
Read more...
yes if you tackle well, this will help out any football team.this is what we both hope our giants do this year.
Read more...
For me is tackling. Give me a good tackling team then I will show you a winner more time than not.
Read more...
think I rather watch a rerun of a "bad" WD episode then a "good" syndicated prime time show anytime!
Read more...

Inside Football News

It’s time for another reader mailbag. With the NFL draft...
Read more...
This is is the March 2017 issue. This is a......
Read more...
Is Eli Manning in for another rough season behind a...
Read more...

Star-Ledger Giants

If the Giants make a surprise pick in the 2017 NFL Draft, who could it be? What's the deal with Johnathan Hankins? Could the Giants re-sign Victor Cruz at some point?
Read more...
The captain of the defense wants the free agent defensive tackle to return.
Read more...
NFL free agency officially opened on Thursday, March 9, 2017 (3/9/17). Many big stars signed with new teams, including cornerback A.J. Bouye with the Jaguars, wide receiver Alshon Jeffery with the Eagles and cornerback Stephon Gilmore with the Patriots. With free agency two weeks old, many of the big names are off the market. But quarterback Jay Cutler and running back Adrian Peterson are still available. Here are the best players available at every position as of Sunday, March 26, 2017 (3/26/17).
Read more...

Big Blue View

Would Giants be interested in a back similar to Paul Perkins and Shane Vereeen? After parting ways with Rashad Jennings and with Shane Vereen entering the final year of his contract, it seems likely that the New York Giants will select a running back at some point in the 2017 NFL Draft. Many Giants fans are looking for bigger, more powerful running backs to partner with Paul Perkins. However, there is something to be said for partnering a smaller, faster running back who might not offer much contrast to Perkins, but would offer fresh legs with similar capabilities....
Read more...
Ryan Ramczyk is choice at 23, let’s see how the rest of the draft played out It’s time for another simulated seven-round mock draft for the New York Giants. This one will use the Fanspeak simulator and the latest CBS Sports Big Board. There is one other stipulation — the last two times I did this the first selection was Utah offensive tackle Garett Bolles. This time, I pre-determined that I would pass on Bolles no matter what the board looked like simply to see how that changed the ultimate outcome. Complete Fanspeak mock Seven-round mock version 1.0 Seven-round mock version...
Read more...
Go to top