For the record- who would you have drafted?

[MightyGiants]

You can take the Giants pick or anyone below that choice (no trades).  I will archive this post so we can revisit it after the season is over.  Feel free to do the top pick or the top 3 or the entire 7 picks.

Here is a helpful link to build your draft list:

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/draft;_ylt=ArCyEAdoptbgaLMqDuCCTPDXb6x_

[President Rick]

I would have taken Pouncey with #15 as a high value and solid need especially in 2011-2012 and beyond, and saved the DE - DT- LB picks for later in rounds 2,3,4, with no safety in rounds 1-4..

[jerseyguy]

I would have taken Weatherspoon, I think he fits our defense and I like his motor and after that I wanted Sean Lee but none of that happened and until I see a reason for it I guess I will always wonder...

[todge]

JPP

[MightyGiants]

1) OC/OG Pouncey
2) DT Williams
3) ILB Butler
4) ILB Phillip Dillard
5) OL Chris Scott
6) RB Jonathan Dwyer
7) P Dodge

[troyfan]

Don't know, but w/ McClain gone I would have traded down.  Or Dan Williams, who I thought should have gone about then but didn't.

[bamagiantfan]

1. Iupati
2. Terrance Cody - so I have little problem with Joseph, a similar pick
3. Donald Butler (LB)  - and be kicking myself that I let Spikes and Angerer slip by in Round 2
4. Matt Tennent (C) - yes, I could have waited and got him in the 5th
5. Greg Hardy (DE) - If he recovers from his injuries, he's a stud
6.  Frisco took Byham!?  . Ok then, James Starks (RB) - As good as anybody in this draft after Spiller and Matthews (jeez I really wanted that blocking TE from Pitt. 
7. I would have passed on Dodge and hoped to sign him as an UDFA. I'd take Blue Cooper (WR) - he sounds like a Giant.

[Cid in Dupont]

I would have taken Pouncey or Morgan.  Otherwise I would have traded down to early 2nd round & taken Lee then and then a DT or another ILB with the 3rd pick.

Cid

[Grime Time]

Tebow... 

[NYSPORTS]

My first pick was Williams yet considering what was on the board, I would have been more conservative and selected DE Morgan.

Pierre-Paul has more upside yet I view Morgan as a safer pick.  He reminds more of the Strahan/Tuck mold while Pierre-Paul reminds me more of Osi.  I don't see Jevon Kearse.

[joeynygiants]

I would had done a poor job, for the giants and you guys knew the players than I do.

[PSUBeirut]

1) Derrick Morgan
2)  Sean Lee
3)  J.D. Walton
4)  Thaddeus Gibson
5)  Mitch Petrus
6)  Jonathon Dwyer
7)  Matt Dodge


I like Morgan better than JPP.  I think we're fine at DT right now.  I like the Joseph pick, but I definitely would have gone with Lee.  Got a good center in round 3 and kept the guard in round 5.  Picked up some RB depth with great value in round 6.  I wanted 2 LB's out of this draft and I think Lee and Gibson would have been great additions!

[Slick]

1.Derrick Morgan
2.Daryl Washington
3.Chad Jones

[Eli10]

1. Morgan
2. Butler
3. Jones

If not Morgan - I would have moved back about 5 spots and grabbed Pouncey or Iupati..

Happy with Rounds 2 and 3 and 4...Not so much on Rd 1 - I will let it play out but see no year 1 help from JPP - situational only..

[todge]

According to Pat at Inside Football - inside sources have stated that Spiller was the Giants' first choice, followed by McClain and then JPP.