Ottis Anderson? 10,273 YDS, 4.0 AVG, 81 TD 3062 YDS Receiving 5 TD Receiving
Tiki Barder? 10,449 YDS, 4.7 AVG, 55 TD 5183 YDS Receiving 12 TD Receiving
Brandon Jacobs? 4849 YRDS, 4.5 AVG 56 TD 730 YDS Receiving 4 TD Receiving
those are the stats. some 'what if's'.....
what if Otis had been a Giant for his whole career?
what if tiki had played 2-3 more?
or if BJ had remained a Giant 2-3 more?
Given the #'s and the fact that Otis was a card most of his years, putting aside a player's personal life, off field comments, sour grapes, stupidity, etc. and for me being objective, looking at running, catching, blocking, and the whole package, and I look at the NY Giants, I'll cast a vote for tiki.