I love Phil Simms. He was my favorite player.
Phil Simms is a terrible broadcaster. Just awful. He doesn't have CTE. He has always been that way. Entirely predictable, never criticizes, sticks with his story line, basically talks 90% of the time about the QB. He makes mistakes, things always happen the opposite of what he says will, and doesn't STOP TALKING FOR EVEN ONE SECOND.
Collinsworth has an annoying voice and he can be smug. BUT his analysis is simply spot-on. The best in the biz as far as I'm concerned.
I never had a problem with Aikman, he does not root for the Cowboys contrary to what many seem to believe, and has good insight into the passing game. He actually seems to have a bit of a soft spot for Eli and the Giants. He has not been a big Romo fan over the years.