I used to hate Collings-un-worth. I think just about everyone thought he was so anti Giants, but now, I really like him. Maybe it's because of the way he gushed (and still does) over OBJ's mind boggling catch, but I enjoy listening to him. He compliments and criticizes when the time is appropriate and he does his homework, something that can't be said for many others. They just show up.
And, personally, I like listening to Gruden. I do believe he falls into the category of just showing up and thinking he can do it all, but to me, he is a sort of breathe of fresh air instead of just hearing XXX'x and OOO's. Maybe he is a John Madden wannabee, but he makes me smile and that is a good thing.