Big Blue Huddle

Given how unpredictable R1 was it is hard to say. My guess is one of Tyler Nubin, Mike Sainristil, TJ Tampa or Braden Fiske if there at 47 unless guys like DeJean or Newton keep falling due to injury concerns.

I understand the pick given his talent and his ability to separate, which Daboll prizes, though I have concerns over his maturity. He is very young and has had some issues. It remains to be seen if we have enough leadership at QB and in the wider locker room to get the best out of him or if he will become a handful down the line. Odunze was the slightly lower ceiling but safer character pick. We will see how it goes. We have to hope DJ or Lock can get him and the rest of a talented but inexperienced WR group the ball!

No.

I think Mike Sainristil will go before Gmen pick.  I like a Guard or RB.  Keep working on the offense.

Probably marginally, but picking Nabers isn't so much about DJ as it is about the next QB.

Will he be better?  Yes, Nabers should provide some nice YAC to bolster DJ's abysmal passing production. Will he magically elevate DJ into the high-volume passer required to compete for SBs in the modern era...NO!

Quote from: sxdxca38 on April 25, 2024, 11:07:07 PMLenn,

In 2022 Daniel Jones had a 93.2 RTG ranked 13th, a 60.2 QBR ranked 6th, and the Giants went 10-7-1 and won a playoff game.

May I ask did you forget about this?

Great, where did the Giants rank in passing yards, passing TDs, and completions?  You know, stats that actually matter to WRs.  @LennG is spot on here.

I love the Nabers pick; after the top 3 QBs came off the board, this was the best option.  Still, the notion Nabers is going to magically evaluate DJ to a top-tier/high-volume passer that's required to win in the modern NFL seems far-fetched.   

And nobody forgot about 2022; we're just not looking at it from a predefined notion in an utter vacuum.  He had a good season relative to his past performances; he did NOT have a good season relative to his contemporaries.  His high rating and QBR were byproducts of being overly conservative, coupled with a really good rushing performance/yards; however, when viewed from a macro perspective (i.e. considering all the data), it was nothing special. After 60 games, I think we all have a good idea of DJ's capabilities...

People that think Belichik is glib and short in the personality department really gonna need a re-think.

BPA for me, within reason. We have too many needs to use a top 50 pick on a RB for example. I also probably wouldn't draft a center, and there is no QB I would take either under any circumstances. I'd probably avoid taking another WR in this round too given we just took one sixth overall. But any of CB, OG, OT, DT, OLB, etc I'd be down with getting the best of. I view CB as perhaps the single biggest need but hardly the only one.

Quote from: uconnjack8 on April 24, 2024, 09:31:06 PMThanks for sharing this annually.

Interesting to see TE Wiley in the 3rd round

I gave him a bump based on need and fact little between prospects in R3/R4 of a draft. Never could see Waller coming back. When you're contemplating retirement, 90% of the time you checked out entirely