Name your pick of any available candidates and why you believe in this candidate. An existing HC is acceptable if it makes sense that he would become available. One post per Member and no debate. Choose your man.
Chuck Pagano. I heard he's available and he's been successful.
Hmmm.....
Probably will get ridiculed but I'm going with McAdoo. I really believe in this offense, I think he is an incredibly talented young coach and I take the chance rolling him with Eli. Worst case in 3 years, he and Eli go together and we start over, best case we have a great offense for years but he must find himself one hell of a D coordinator and that worries me but like I said I roll with it and see what happens since either way in 3 years there will be some drop off when Eli gets close to 40.
I want mcDermott - A younger DC, who came up the scouting ranks.
Unless Dave Gentlemen gives a glowing recommendation I do not think they would hire him though.
Yep, I agree...almost has to be Mac...
Eli on Francesca....he wants to stay in this offense , he wants Mac.
You can't bring in a head coach and stick him with someone else's coordinators , so I really don't see what choice they have.
Get David Shaw in here. Failing that, Hue Jackson. He reminds me of Arians.
But I'm willing to bet top money that they will go with McAdoo. Can't wait for the reactions on this board to that one.
Sean Payton
The only decent option available
The Carolina D coordinator or David Shaw. A new direction with no ties to the Giants, please.
1st choice: Sean Payton
Sean's been around the block and is a no-nonsense coach. He can get the most out of this offense and is familiar with NY Giants football. If he can land a solid defensive coordinator, we should be good.
2nd choice: Josh McDaniels
He's had his chance in Denver and it didn't fare very well. I believe he's learned a lot from Little Bill from their years together and there doesn't seem to be any animosity as he's on his second stint under BB in NE. Although he has no ties to the Giants, Bill does. And bringing a little bit of the Patriots way to NY isn't a bad thing from my perspective. I would think he's learned from his Denver days and would presumably do things differently if he had another chance at HC.
I've been championing McDermott for two months, he'll be our Mike Tomlin right down to the William and Mary pedigree.
Is TC available? If so, TC.
The instructions were pretty simple. Pick your HC. No debate or editorial or breaking someone's chops for their pick.
The 2 Mc's...McDaniels or McAdoo.
Change the strength & conditioning coach, let Reese do the talent evals, and keep spags.
If we hire McD, then keep McA as OC.
Cid
My pick would be Payton, hands down.
Todd Haley.
Payton if he can get out of his contract or McDaniels.
Spags
and keeping Macadoo as OC. bring in a young DC and we are all set.
McDermott I guess, but I have little enthusiasm for him.
I have a strong hunch it will be McAdoo.
20 years of wilderness wandering I see ahead for this team.
I'd like Bill O'Brien if he was interested in leaving the Texans.
mcadoo is the right choice, eli likes him.
mcdaniels would be good too.
davis shaw is mt final pick.
Here's a list from MSN.com
http://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/10-best-potential-giants-replacements-for-tom-coughlin/ar-AAgl9ZN?li=BBnb7Kz (http://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/10-best-potential-giants-replacements-for-tom-coughlin/ar-AAgl9ZN?li=BBnb7Kz)
Sean McDermott....Could be a long wait though.
David Shaw.
Quote from: LennG on January 04, 2016, 08:51:26 PM
Spags
and keeping Macadoo as OC. bring in a young DC and we are all set.
You beat me to it, Lenny. That's exactly what I was going to say. :ok:
Doug Marrone....9 wins with Kyle Orton in Buffalo and fired for "sexy Rexy". ????
You can dictate to him that McAdoo is his OC and let him go from there.
None of the suggestions fixes the "talent procurement" problem that we have. But al least we know Reese's real job is to be the insulating, well paid buffer for the Mara's.
Bring in chip Kelly. I feel this is a no-brainer.
I think chip is an innovator on offense and can work with Eli manning.
I understand chip Kelly inherited a 4-12 team & won the division.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
Doug Marrone.
Bill Cowher, an established winner with the Steelers, if he can be coaxed from CBS.
Otherwise, Sean Paton.
Mark
Nick Saban - 5 year gig. He retires when Eli retires
It would be David Shaw if he would come.
Assuming he won't I'd say Hue Jackson.
Sean McDermott. Carolina DC.
Quote from: quacker on January 04, 2016, 07:18:35 PM
Chuck Pagano. I heard he's available and he's been successful.
Apparently Pagano and the Colts are kissing and making up so my choice now would be Spags.
Quote from: PSUBeirut on January 04, 2016, 09:05:55 PM
I'd like Bill O'Brien if he was interested in leaving the Texans.
I would've loved this, but it looks like he's planted in Texas.
Quote from: Philosophers on January 05, 2016, 01:12:14 AM
Nick Saban - 5 year gig. He retires when Eli retires
Apparently he said he would consider the New York Giants and one other organization if Alabama wins the National Championship this year.
Roll Tide!
Sean Payton. Keep Mac and Spags as the coordinators. He already worked with Spags in NO and I believe he can work with Mac.
Saban.
Pick your HC. No debate or editorial or breaking someone's chops for their pick...
.
As long as we don't give up a draft pick to get a coach, which I think is stupid when you draft at #10!
They could give Spoags the HC job and keep Mc Adoo and move forward.
More than anything this team needs defense.
Again,I think it would be stupid to give up a draft choice or draft choices for a Coach.
Me
Truthfully, the way things are playing out...I wouldn't mind seeing Jon Gruden (I swear, I would've never said that a year ago!)
But given the current climate of coaches on the horizon, and the intrigue of adding a sibling rivalry to a natural division rival...I am beginning to warm to the idea.
Bill Belichick
not joking
I will start out thinking that Doug Marrone is the correct choice. No need to explain other than to say that I have read a number of positive comment on other blogs that were compelling enough to overcome my distaste of the way that he left Buffalo.
Gruden would be great or Saban if Gruden turns us down
Dabo Swinney Clemson must be doing something right GO GIANTS
Quote from: Mikey Ravioli on January 06, 2016, 04:38:33 PM
Bill Belichick
not joking
Mikey: If Brady were to announce his retirement after they get knocked out of the playoffs, it becomes a possibility, IMO, but I don't think he's ready to hang up his cleats yet. One or two more years, IMO.
Bob
PS. A tip-of-the-hat for thinking outside the box (and for courage. . . LOL).
PPS. Mikey, just found this . . . so there are at least THREE of us loons =)) . . . . . . http://ferrall.radio.cbssports.com/2016/01/06/why-bill-belichick-might-actually-want-new-york-giants-job/ (http://ferrall.radio.cbssports.com/2016/01/06/why-bill-belichick-might-actually-want-new-york-giants-job/)
Honestly none of the names being associated with the Giants really excites me. Of all the guys I have looked at (I tend to research these guys) the only one that seems to have a resume that makes me think he could be successful is Lovie Smith, so that's my answer.
So far we know that the short-list contains.....
Ben McAdoo
Steve Spagnuolo
Adam Gase
Doug Marrone
Sean McDermott
Terryl Austin
It may have contained Sean Peyton but he's no longer in consideration
No 'big names' on that short-list as yet but no one who has failed dismally as a HC besides Spagnuolo (courtesy interview).
Even balance of OC's and DC's
Lovie Smith,
Second choice Doug Marrone.
Dream choice Bill Belichick.
So far with 2 or more votes and first choice of multiple votes.
McDermott- 6 Votes
Spagnuolo- 4 Votes
3 Votes
McAdoo
Shaw
McDaniels
Marrone
2 Votes
Saban
Gruden
Lovey Smith
Quote from: Vette on January 07, 2016, 03:09:25 PM
So far with 2 or more votes and first choice of multiple votes.
McDermott- 6 Votes
Spagnuolo- 4 Votes
3 Votes
McAdoo
Shaw
McDaniels
Marrone
2 Votes
Saban
Gruden
Ed,
I believe Lovie Smith has at least 2
no one stated david and mike shula or kyle shanahan.
Quote from: MightyGiants on January 07, 2016, 03:24:09 PM
Ed,
I believe Lovie Smith has at least 2
You're right, thanks.
I wouldn't have a problem with Lovie at all. But I think McDermott more so. Shaw and Saban really have great situations-why leave? McDaniels seems a stretch to me with Eli so enamored with McAdoo and the team needing a presence, a gravitas too. Lovie has that kind of respect with players, although he chose badly with the Glazers.
I wanna see Jim Schwartz involved somewhere and if Marrone is the HC I think JS is the DC.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Quote from: MightyGiants on January 07, 2016, 07:53:22 AM
Honestly none of the names being buttociated with the Giants really excites me.
Interesting, yet appropriate, word choice.
Quote from: MP21WAYS2PAY on January 07, 2016, 04:29:08 PM
Interesting, yet appropriate, word choice.
I just adjusted the system censor for the letters ass as it is in many words. lol
Quote from: Vette on January 07, 2016, 04:38:02 PM
I just adjusted the system censor for the letters ass as it is in many words. lol
I kind of like it. I vote to keep it. Maybe a new poll?
I;m changing my vote
Lovie Smith
Lovie Smith is up there. Much more appealing than the safe from a Giants' standpoint but risky from a long term look, of McAdoo. Talk about overrated.
I am going with Doug Marrone. The more I think about this, the more I like it.
Quote from: Jintsman74 on January 07, 2016, 11:58:24 PM
I am going with Doug Marrone. The more I think about this, the more I like it.
Yeah, I said in another thread I'd like Marrone and Schwartz as the DC.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk