Justin Herbert- proof that just adding an elite QB will turn around a franchise

[Philosophers]

No QB would do well under DeVito's 9 sack assault.  We might as well draft a kicker to play QB.

[Uni]

No QB would do well under DeVito's 9 sack assault.  We might as well draft a kicker to play QB.

You mean no QB other than Tommy DeVito?

Sent from my SM-S911U using Tapatalk

[Doc16LT56]

No QB would do well under DeVito's 9 sack assault.  We might as well draft a kicker to play QB.

How long has it been since Daniel Jones threw for 3 TDs in a game? He hasn't done it in the last 4 years.

The QB isn't as helpless as you pretend in order to justify the Daniel Jones experiment.

[Woody]

Haskins is no where in the class of anyone at the top of this QB group. Please be serious.

But he was the year he was drafted.     That is the point


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Dgoodmantrublu]

Most of the sacks were on DeVito. He got sacked on a quick screen he decided not to throw. I've never seen that in the NFL

[Woody]

I was not disrespectful of Haskins I was just making point that he was suppose to be one of the better Qb' s that year and he did not pan out as a player....you guys need to get a life


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Dgoodmantrublu]

He was never graded as a top prospect. Just one of the top guys in a very weak class. There are 6 guys in this class who are better prospects than he was. The comparison holds no water.

I was not disrespectful of Haskins I was just making point that he was suppose to be one of the better Qb' s that year and he did not pan out as a player....you guys need to get a life


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Philosophers]

How long has it been since Daniel Jones threw for 3 TDs in a game? He hasn't done it in the last 4 years.

The QB isn't as helpless as you pretend in order to justify the Daniel Jones experiment.

Ok you realize that your sample size to make your point was 1 game right?  If we looked back for all the 9 sack games a QB experienced, I'd wager confidently the QB lost 90%+ of them.  What DeVito did was great but that will not happen again IMHO.

I do agree QBs can be a reason for sacks.  I used to say Eli was responsible for a lot of his sacks because his drop back was sooooo slow.

[DaveBrown74]

We can blame today's close loss on Herbert.

Or......


https://twitter.com/sharpfootball/status/1726347283124404569?s=46&t=6_OiGHiF_HZTCU3XOwUQ5Q

[Doc16LT56]

Ok you realize that your sample size to make your point was 1 game right?

That's one game Daniel Jones hasn't produced in the last 4 years. The point is an undrafted rookie walked in the door and is immediately more productive than Daniel Jones with 6 TD passes in his 3 starts. That doesn't mean DeVito is the answer. It's just further confirmation that Daniel Jones is an enormous part of the problem for the Giants.

Again, the QB can make plays regardless of his circumstances. It won't happen consistently if the team isn't good enough. But if DeVito can throw for 6 TDs in 3 games, then no reasonable person should continue making excuses for Daniel Jones.

[MagicRat]

It's hard to say how many of the sacks were on Tommy without seeing coach's film.
But to my eye at least two were.
The one mentioned when the line released on the right for a screen on the left and one where Barklay had a step on an outside go route.
Both of those were designed and he seemed to freeze in the pocket.

[Philosophers]

That's one game Daniel Jones hasn't produced in the last 4 years. The point is an undrafted rookie walked in the door and is immediately more productive than Daniel Jones with 6 TD passes in his 3 starts. That doesn't mean DeVito is the answer. It's just further confirmation that Daniel Jones is an enormous part of the problem for the Giants.

Again, the QB can make plays regardless of his circumstances. It won't happen consistently if the team isn't good enough. But if DeVito can throw for 6 TDs in 3 games, then no reasonable person should continue making excuses for Daniel Jones.

We agree that DJ is not the answer.