Schoen defended his no QB draft and mentioned "Tommy"

[AZGiantFan]

one must not forget Tommy got thrown to the beast with little preparation

he kook the opportunity and beat Philly, his throws along the boundaries are world class

he keeps his head together and inspires the offense and never panics

Brown and Id dare say Lock do not posses this kind of polish and confidence...sorry but the Jersey Tomato is the best of the lot by far.  I think Schoen knows this too

Will dump Brown at ist opportuity, disregard Lock and promote Tommy who has gotten lots of reps running the practice teaming will be ready when called

I admire your tenacity, if not your judgement.

Oh, by the way, who is Brown?

[BluesCruz]

I admire your tenacity, if not your judgement.

Oh, by the way, who is Brown?

Jones, Brown whatever lousy QB Duke is sending our way next LOL
I cannot believe Jones was that easily forgettable.   Whatever
we must watch this clown show once again and it will not be pretty

Tommy will ready when inevitably called to arms

[WheresDayne]

Is this entire thread a satire?   

[Ed Vette]

If Tommy was in this years draft, he would have been sitting at a bar in downtown Detroit with Sam Hartman watching the draft.

Everyone likes Tommy and I hope he does well, but the Giants aren't going to carry three QB's and he's not making the final roster unless Jones or Lock get injured or traded. He's going to hit the waver wire and if he clears, he will wind up on the practice squad.

[TONKA56]

Is this entire thread a satire?   

The world will never know. Good old BluesCruz...the Andy Kaufman of BBH. 

[Jclayton92]

I guess we are just ignoring that Devito got benched last year lol.

[TONKA56]

I guess we are just ignoring that Devito got benched last year lol.

Plenty of hall of fame quarterbacks have been benched. What matters is how he responds. 

[BluesCruz]

If Tommy was in this years draft, he would have been sitting at a bar in downtown Detroit with Sam Hartman watching the draft.

Everyone likes Tommy and I hope he does well, but the Giants aren't going to carry three QB's and he's not making the final roster unless Jones or Lock get injured or traded. He's going to hit the waver wire and if he clears, he will wind up on the practice squad.

no way in HADES  he clears now...that train has left the station

hopefully They ditch Lock in camp or Danny Dimes is not ready to go until Christmas

It must be painful to realize DeVito is the only NFL QB on the roster

Dimes is only on the roster because of Mara's man love

[Uncle Mickey]

I like Tommy. I do. However Tommy doesn't have nearly the upside of Jones. Jones high level plays be it throws or runs are higher than any high level throws of anyone on the team. Everyone of us , though we have short memory, have seen numerous 'wow' plays from Daniel. That is fact. It is evident when watching the top plays of each QB on the team he ca make the rare and special throws. The question is is DJ's ability to process the field seem compromised because he is just not great in this area or is it more due to a historically bad offensive line combined with well below average WRs. 

This is what this year should bear out for us. I am truly hoping it's the latter. Because if so, we would have that guy who has had made some very high level plays in his career playing at that high level a lot more consistently with the better support system around him.

[BluesCruz]

Tommy seems to be quite under-rated because of his pre-nfl portfolio. I watched a couple of his games and I really think the kid has some special ability. He has a pretty good arm. He is accurate and throws some catchable balls. His pocket presence is excellent. He can buy time and hit the target running. If no one is open he tries to run or secures the ball for minimal loss. In the Washington game, behind that atrocious line, he was sacked 9 times, but was still able to throw some nice completions and win the game.

On the Jets game, I think, they tied his hands and he still almost won that game! He could have been 4-1, in 5 games with a lousy O line and average targets.

BRAVO BRAVO {Applause from me} and my candidate for post of the decade

VERY BRAVE and astute of you with this crowd.  Most would not know a good QB if he landed on them.  Jones has issues long and on the border that are unsolvable
not to mention zero pocket presence

PS- Now that Phil Simms has lost his job- a shame because he really knows his stuff.  Phil should be invited to camp to school the 3 QBs a bit

[BluesCruz]

I like Tommy. I do. However Tommy doesn't have nearly the upside of Jones. Jones high level plays be it throws or runs are higher than any high level throws of anyone on the team. Everyone of us , though we have short memory, have seen numerous 'wow' plays from Daniel. That is fact. It is evident when watching the top plays of each QB on the team he ca make the rare and special throws. The question is is DJ's ability to process the field seem compromised because he is just not great in this area or is it more due to a historically bad offensive line combined with well below average WRs. 

This is what this year should bear out for us. I am truly hoping it's the latter. Because if so, we would have that guy who has had made some very high level plays in his career playing at that high level a lot more consistently with the better support system around him.

Jones is the "Mechanical Man". WYSG.  What you see is what you are going to get .... now minus the running with the bad neck and knee

[Uncle Mickey]

Jones is the "Mechanical Man". WYSG.  What you see is what you are going to get .... now minus the running with the bad neck and knee

Team fixes OL or gets a dominant WR or both. Incumbent QB's confidence and production (if the QB is truly talented) suddenly goes up and is more consistent. Seen this rodeo play out too many times to assume our QB stinks just yet.

[BluesCruz]

Team fixes OL or gets a dominant WR or both. Incumbent QB's confidence and production (if the QB is truly talented) suddenly goes up and is more consistent. Seen this rodeo play out too many times to assume our QB stinks just yet.

Believe me Uncle he STINKS and the stink will get far worse without the 700 yds running

[BluesCruz]

The world will never know. Good old BluesCruz...the Andy Kaufman of BBH. 

Thanks I admired Andy.  A brave comedian to the end....appreciate the allusion

I speak my mind and in my mind the truth.  This entire post 2011 era has been a continual mind blowing sea of Giants ineptitude

Someone has to call them out.  A free medium coke once a decade just does not satisfy my thirst for another Lombardy

I'm sure, I could run this franchise far better than Mara and his Clown Toot Toot Train

Too much fraternity and aspiring for mediocrity as a goal

Mara needs to lose his man love for bad players and and bad play and bring in the GOAT- Belicheck and give him total control

[GloryDays]

For me, I am excited about watching this competition, but I hope it is a real one and the best man will be chosen to lead our team back to glory soon.