Tommy or Tyrod?

[MightyGiants]

Assuming Tyrod comes off IR after the bye, who would you start on Monday Night against the Packers?

[andrew_nyGiants]

Tommy.
I'd like to see if we can get a look up (as in near his ceiling) to see what he truly has between now and the end of the season.

We know what Tyrod has, and chances are with this OL, we'll probably see him again anyway.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[T200]

Let TD Tommy finish the season. If Tyrod plays another game, we'll end up seeing Tommy anyway.

[EDjohnst1981]

Let's see what there is in Tommy the rest of the way.

You can't evaluate what you have with a sub-par line and WRs in just 2 games.

[Giant Jim]

Tommy, he'll probably have to start the first few games next year too until Jones, you remember him, is ready.

[Ed Vette]

As a fan, I'd like to stick with Tommy. As the HC, Daboll has to weigh putting the better QB in TT on the field against the catalyst Tommy has become in energizing this team.

[MightyGiants]

As a fan, I'd like to stick with Tommy. As the HC, Daboll has to weigh putting the better QB in TT on the field against the catalyst Tommy has become in energizing this team.

I agree; plus, at this point, the Jersey Boy makes a good story of Tommy D is the only bright spot of a dismal season.   

The last time the Giants had the local guy make good was Victor Cruz.

[T200]

As a fan, I'd like to stick with Tommy. As the HC, Daboll has to weigh putting the better QB in TT on the field against the catalyst Tommy has become in energizing this team.

Tyrod is the better QB but TD Tommy is getting wins.

[Philosophers]

Let the kid play.  Season is lost anyway.

[DaveBrown74]

I'm rather indifferent myself. The season is long over and, while the Tommy D story is fun and I really like the kid and all the hoopla around him, neither of these individuals is likely to have any sort of material impact on the team over the medium to longer term.

For short term entertainment purposes I guess I hope they keep Tommy D in there, and I think it's reasonable to say he has earned that opportunity, but I don't care a great deal either way really. There are simply much bigger fish to fry in terms of pondering the general state of affairs with this team and its future.

[Bob In PA]

No reason to change away from a QB who won two games in a row. I can't think of one good reason. Bob

[TDToomer]

Reality check. Any of the 3 Giants QBS could have won the last 2 games. Jones almost never loses to Washington, Tyrod beat them earlier this season and 10 points beats the Patriots.

I will let Daboll make this decision and I think it will be a tough one for him. Both should be ready to play.

[coggs]

I agree; plus, at this point, the Jersey Boy makes a good story of Tommy D is the only bright spot of a dismal season.   

The last time the Giants had the local guy make good was Victor Cruz.

Are you really comparing the DeVito story to the Cruz story?

[coggs]

I don't think it matters.  Both are terrible.  Only way they win another game is if the D wins the turnover battle by a good margin and sets the offense up with a short field enough times to squeak by.

[LennG]

Not to hijack this thread but are we sure we are still playing on MNF?. Can they move a bad game for something else?