Big Blue Huddle

I went with Robinson because whoever is our QB needs a reliable WR he can depend on. Robinson in the slot can do some good things. Just has to stay healthy.

I think Jones will be a fine backup. If you needed him for a few games - he could get the job done.

17 games? Not so much.

Quote from: DaveBrown74 on March 30, 2024, 07:33:22 AMIt's very obvious many here significantly Williams or are down on him as a prospect. That is fine, but it's kind of irrelevant. There is zero chance he will be a Giant in 2024.

Williams is still the blue chipper in this class. I think he's still in his own tier.

His 40 time is pretty irrelevant since he doesn't run. And he doesn't throw the ball to well on the run either.

No - only because I don't think Penix is long for the NFL.

Everything in the Gettleman Era. Set the team back at least 5-8 years.

To be honest - he would be on a lot of teams do not draft list.

There's a ton of baggage coming with him.

There's mix messages on whether Schoen is there.

Some reporters are saying he will be. Some saying he won't be.

If Harrison has been told by Arizona or SD at 4 or 5 - there's really no need to do anything.

I think Arizona has told them he won't get past them at 4.

If we don't get a QB, I'd be more than happy with Nabers or Odunze.

Quote from: katkavage on March 19, 2024, 11:51:47 AMIf the staff is not up to a rookie QB, the Giants need a new staff. And you want to wait until all is good around this rookie? Keep waiting...and waiting...and waiting. We can enjoy more mediocrity while we wait. There is no perfect scenario. Your guy is there, take him. End of story. There won't be other chances.

Oh I agree we need a QB and have to take them. My point is that there are situations that are really temping for new QBs and others not so much. And lets say Maye is the 4th QB taken - he may have a better career than Daniels or Williams - but it may be becaue his situation was better.

No matter who goes where withthe top 4 QB - they all need support staffs from coaches and players to be successful. The 3rd or 4th QB taken could be more successful than the first QB taken but it doesnt necessarily mean he is better.

Look at Minnesota.
- good OL
- Best WR in the game
- very good up and coming number 2 WR is Addison
- very good TE

Whoeever goes there will be starting off on the right foot!

I think they're getting closer. If the OLine can be a solid group and draft a WR in round 2. Our defense should be pretty decent.

May take a year or two but we seem to be finally heading in the right direction.

Quote from: DaveBrown74 on March 17, 2024, 10:27:54 AMHow can anyone be "right" or "wrong" about a player who hasn't even been drafted yet, let alone set foot on an NFL field even once?

The same way people proclaiming he is a bust even before even being drafted haha

26 pages of nonsense?

Very mature repsonse