NGT - Is Justin Herbert good?

[PSUBeirut]

Seems like an appropriate stat to share here:
https://x.com/Ihartitz/status/1716859771595235769?s=20

I'm moving more toward the feeling that he ain't all that great.  Might be a great fantasy football QB but I just don't think he's accurate, a gamer, or a guy who elevates the team around him. 

[Bob In PA]

Seems like an appropriate stat to share here:
https://x.com/Ihartitz/status/1716859771595235769?s=20

I'm moving more toward the feeling that he ain't all that great.  Might be a great fantasy football QB but I just don't think he's accurate, a gamer, or a guy who elevates the team around him. 

PSU: IMO, like Jones, he is dependent on the quality of other offensive personnel who surround him.

EVERY quarterback in the NFL is, although some ARE more to be able to overcome more adversity than others.

Sadly, it's almost impossible to prove the latter statement.  I wish we could place Jones on the Chiefs or Eagles for just one week, and move their QB's to the Giants, because I would dearly love to be conclusively proven wrong (or right) about this.

Bob

[ralphpal1]

Is hurts playing good this season ? Something is off. HE is winning but he has 7 interceptions and he isnt the same
But winning.is all.that matters

[umassgrad]

Herbert is much better than anyone QB on the Giants roster and it's not even close.

[kartanoman]

That's a very appropriate comparison as well.

Not the Kirk Cousins who out-duelled "the" Mr. Irrelevant himself on Monday Night Football!

Admittedly, I'll turn on the Chargers games and my take is that the kid, when he's on his game, can match it with any of the game's greatest gunslingers. When he's not, then that's another story. He's been inconsistent so far this season. He's short a WR and a TE, I believe, as well as his center, but He's a four year pro who is supposed to adjust and overcome, right?

Peace!