Should Kafka get the axe?

[B1GBLUE]

we are currently ranked 32nd in basically EVERY single category. yes there have been injuries and personnel issues, but this is as bad as it gets. you never know, sometimes changing things up can create a spark.

[Ed Vette]

He should definitely get his arce out of that booth and on the field with his players.

[MightyGiants]

I want to see how things play out as the line stabilizes

[Ed Vette]

I wonder if he sits in a booth at the practice field.

[Ed Vette]

As the President of the Kevin Gilbride fan club of North America, I declare this Offense broken!

[katkavage]

After the season changes should obviously be made.

[T200]

Been saying he needs to be gone for over a month now.

I get the offensive line injuries and understand how the lack of chemistry up front will kill an offense. He has done very little to call plays to maximize the talents/skills of his players. There were minimal rollouts and plays to move the pocket for Jones. No screens to alleviate the quick pressure up the middle. Very few shots downfield to move the secondary out of the box.

Yeah. He needs to be fired. Maybe he wants to be back in KC now that Bienemy is gone.

[Ed Vette]

Been saying he needs to be gone for over a month now.

I get the offensive line injuries and understand how the lack of chemistry up front will kill an offense. He has done very little to call plays to maximize the talents/skills of his players. There were minimal rollouts and plays to move the pocket for Jones. No screens to alleviate the quick pressure up the middle. Very few shots downfield to move the secondary out of the box.

Yeah. He needs to be fired. Maybe he wants to be back in KC now that Bienemy is gone.

Daboll should have hired Bienemy. Daboll can finish the season calling the plays and bring in a complimentary OC next year.

[TDToomer]

I have a different angle. Get out of that comfy warm sky booth and get your ass onto the sidelines and work face to face with your QB and his players while they are off the field. Why isn't he on the sidelines?

[Ed Vette]

I have a different angle. Get out of that comfy warm sky booth and get your ass onto the sidelines and work face to face with your QB and his players while they are off the field. Why isn't he on the sidelines?

I said that.

[madbadger]

I'd love to see what he is as a coordinator when he has his starting quarterback healthy, Barkley healthy and a mediocre offensive line. In all honesty I don't think Andy Reid would be getting much more out of this offense right now.

[DaveBrown74]

I voted no.

I think the Giants need to move away from this model of constantly always firing people every two years.

[nb587]

Last year, people were very worried that Kafka was leaving for a HC job and we were lucky he didn't get one.  Now, I'm reading this stuff.

[DaveBrown74]

Last year, people were very worried that Kafka was leaving for a HC job and we were lucky he didn't get one.  Now, I'm reading this stuff.

Exactly. The fan base is very reactionary. But our owner has been too.

[B1GBLUE]

I have a different angle. Get out of that comfy warm sky booth and get your ass onto the sidelines and work face to face with your QB and his players while they are off the field. Why isn't he on the sidelines?

Is there any evidence OC's on the sidelines have more success than booth guys?