How are we at Safety?

[brownelvis54]

How do you feel about our current Safety situation? If you were GM you leave things the way they are? The greatest question mark IMI is what to do with Xavier McKinney. How much would you be willing to spend? Can you get better or about the same in FA, and cheaper? As the GM, you would be held to the same issues as Joe has. Too many needs and too little money.


Jason Pinnock and Dane Belton are keepers for sure. Gervarrius Owens? Cheap rookie, Can one of these three be a SS? Can one of our corners Tre Hawkins III? Fill in as a safety?

[MightyGiants]

The new DC seems to lean heavily on safeties, the the Giants will need to shore up this unit by keeping McKinney or adding through the draft or free agency

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/Mack_D3/status/1754913960891994615?s=20

[Ed Vette]

They need to sign McKinney.

[MightyGiants]

They need to sign McKinney.

He's going to be expensive, but if they don't that's yet another hole to fill

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/ConklinLance/status/1754923478724010342?s=20

[Jolly Blue Giant]

At the risk of being redundant, "WE MUST RE-SIGN MCKINNEY". If we do, we're good with him and Pinnock. I'm sure we'll draft another or pick up a UDFA after the draft to groom. As long as we keep McKinney, we're in good shape here

[Stringer Bell]

I like McKinney as much as anyone. In fact, safety has always been the position I've been the biggest fan of.

Despite those things, I don't think we should give McKinney big money. If he was willing to sign a below-market deal, I'd be all over it. But there is 0% chance that happens. Someone is going to pay him A LOT of money, and I just hope it's not the Giants.

As I posted on a different thread, it has never made sense to pay a safety big money outside of 2 guys - Reed and Lott.

Out of 5 top-paid safeties in the league right now - James, Fitzpatrick, Adams, Bates, and Smith - not one is worth the money they're signed for.

I'm guessing the floor and comp for a McKinney deal is Justin Simmons' 4-year, $61 million deal. No way I'm looking to pay a "just" top 10 safety that kind of money.

[brownelvis54]

Looks like 10 Million

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/new-york-giants/xavier-mckinney-47631/market-value/

[Sem]

There are questions about starters and backups that they need resolve:

Unknown, at least to us:
- Does McKinney even want to stay? If he does would the Giants be
willing to pay his asking price?

- How do they feel about Gervarrius Owens?

- How comfortable are they that Belton can be a full time starter?

What the Giants do in FA and the draft, regarding the Safety position, will likely be largely dependant on the answers to these questions.

[TDToomer]

Just my monthly reminder that the Giants have not extended or resigned a safety that they had previously drafted since Shawn Williams in 2002.

[Stringer Bell]

Looks like 10 Million

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/new-york-giants/xavier-mckinney-47631/market-value/

I'd be willing to bet any amount of money that $10M doesn't come close to getting it done. He'll be at 40-50% higher than that at $14M-$15M per, at minimum.

[gregf]

Sure, it will be expensive,  but he's a young quality player.  I'd pass on  Barkley, Glow, and Adoree to get it done

[brownelvis54]

I'd be willing to bet any amount of money that $10M doesn't come close to getting it done. He'll be at 40-50% higher than that at $14M-$15M per, at minimum.

You are probably right. Look at Kamren Curl same age too



https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/washington-commanders/kamren-curl-47814/market-value/

[brownelvis54]

They need to sign McKinney.

Just my monthly reminder that the Giants have not extended or resigned a safety that they had previously drafted since Shawn Williams in 2002.

I hope this changes