Moderation Team: Vette, babywhales, Bob In PA, gregf, bighitterdalama, beaugestus, T200
Owner: MightyGiants
MastodonQuote from: Jclayton92 on Today at 09:03:10 PMWho Starts? As the roster stands today before we have any camp cuts or additional signings there are several spots up for grabs. I'm going to list the open positions as I see them and tell you who I project to start, could be a dark horse candidate, or maybe the answer is not on the roster currently.
Who do you have currently?
1. CB2- I actually have Flott starting here over McCloud, Robinson, Hawkins, and Phillips.
2. Slot- Currently I have Phillips as my starter in the slot with Belton as the heavy nickel and Mills as the 4th corner in dime packages.
3. Safety- I have Pinnock locked into the FS spot and Nubin penciled in as the SS with Belton being the 3rd while backing up Nubin and Owens backing up Pinnock. I think Mills floats which is why I don't have him listed here.
4. MLB2- Isaiah Simmons, I think our DC finally places Simmons in a starting role with Muassu technically being behind him and McFadden behind Bobby OK
5. LDE- I have Dex and RNR starting, I have Riley taking snaps at LDE until we sign someone to compete with Davidson and Phillips rotating with the 3. I expect 2 signings here.
6. WR lineup- To start the season I don't have Nabers in the starting lineup. I have Slayton X, Wandale slot, Hyatt Z, and McKenzie as the top 4. Daboll has brought every Wr he's drafted in slow and made them earn time. I think that us your top 4 with Nabers taking reps at every position slowly getting sprinkled in.
RB2- We have Singletary, he's the defacto but number 2 is wide open. One of the backs is going to show out in preseason and be that guy and my guess is Miller with Tracy as number 3. I think Gray got in the dog house last season and until he gets out I have to choose someone else.
TE- I am acting like Waller isn't coming back so I am taking Theo Johnson over Bellinger. My reasoning for that is them drafting Bellinger and then after his solid rookie year the trade for Waller, then the next year sign 2 TEs and draft another one. Obviously they don't like what they got with Bellinger and so if Theo shows a spark I look for him to get the nod over Bellinger.
Who do you have? Any darkhorses? Any players you see taking the next step?
For reference I didn't touch the Oline as I see it as Thomas, Runyan, JMS, Elemeunor, Neal until I see otherwise so there's not much to discuss.
Quote from: Jclayton92 on Today at 09:03:10 PMWho Starts? As the roster stands today before we have any camp cuts or additional signings there are several spots up for grabs. I'm going to list the open positions as I see them and tell you who I project to start, could be a dark horse candidate, or maybe the answer is not on the roster currently.IGood job.
Who do you have currently?
1. CB2- I actually have Flott starting here over McCloud, Robinson, Hawkins, and Phillips.
2. Slot- Currently I have Phillips as my starter in the slot with Belton as the heavy nickel and Mills as the 4th corner in dime packages.
3. Safety- I have Pinnock locked into the FS spot and Nubin penciled in as the SS with Belton being the 3rd while backing up Nubin and Owens backing up Pinnock. I think Mills floats which is why I don't have him listed here.
4. MLB2- Isaiah Simmons, I think our DC finally places Simmons in a starting role with Muassu technically being behind him and McFadden behind Bobby OK
5. LDE- I have Dex and RNR starting, I have Riley taking snaps at LDE until we sign someone to compete with Davidson and Phillips rotating with the 3. I expect 2 signings here.
6. WR lineup- To start the season I don't have Nabers in the starting lineup. I have Slayton X, Wandale slot, Hyatt Z, and McKenzie as the top 4. Daboll has brought every Wr he's drafted in slow and made them earn time. I think that us your top 4 with Nabers taking reps at every position slowly getting sprinkled in.
RB2- We have Singletary, he's the defacto but number 2 is wide open. One of the backs is going to show out in preseason and be that guy and my guess is Miller with Tracy as number 3. I think Gray got in the dog house last season and until he gets out I have to choose someone else.
TE- I am acting like Waller isn't coming back so I am taking Theo Johnson over Bellinger. My reasoning for that is them drafting Bellinger and then after his solid rookie year the trade for Waller, then the next year sign 2 TEs and draft another one. Obviously they don't like what they got with Bellinger and so if Theo shows a spark I look for him to get the nod over Bellinger.
Who do you have? Any darkhorses? Any players you see taking the next step?
For reference I didn't touch the Oline as I see it as Thomas, Runyan, JMS, Elemeunor, Neal until I see otherwise so there's not much to discuss.
Quote from: Thegratefulhead on Today at 10:01:19 PMI think this is fair. I wanted McCarthy at 6. I feel Jones is an injury risk, yet, I have not seen the actual medicals and have not been present for his recovery. From an above orbit, risk management standpoint, having Jones replacement on hand seemed valid. That said, in this offense in particular, Jones can succeed. He can throw short passes to playmakers. The best Jones has had is crappy playmakers in a system designed to have them. Daboll/Kafka system doesn't work without YAC. I want to see the kid with an average OL and some playmakers. I think his body ends up betraying him. If Jones is healthy he will look good in this system I suspect with these playmakers.
Nabers is a beast, a true number 1 changes everything.
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 01:18:22 PMSchoen has clearly indicated that there isn't a quarterback competition. Yet, you have Garafolo suggesting Lock might be able to compete. Will Lock be the starter or could there be a QB competition in camp?GM Schneider's claim was rebuked by Lock himself. He said the Giants told him they were bringing him in to be the backup.
https://twitter.com/awthentik/status/1785074659907584277
Now you have this:
Ryan Dunleavy
@rydunleavy
Theres more smoke around Drew Lock being #Giants starting QB over Daniel Jones, after #Seahawks GM Jon Schneider's comments earlier
@MoveTheSticks
podcast: 'I believe Drew Lock has a really good shot of winning that job.'
'They were comparing Daniel Jones and Drew Lock — emphasis on Drew Lock — to the QBs that were going to be there (in the draft) and I think the line for them was Drake Maye.'
This runs VERY contradictory to what Joe Schoen is saying publicly about Daniel Jones. They havent even opened it up to competition yet. But privately?
Remember, Daniel Jeremiah was ahead of the curve on Giants not drafting JJ McCarthy, too
https://x.com/rydunleavy/status/1785357074852970740
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 09:41:40 PMThis is a very inaccurate framing of the sides and the issues. Based on this very thread, here is a proper description of the "sides."- On the one hand, you have people who are saying not to write Jones off just yet. They are not saying he will, but they are not ruling out the possibility that he will be successful again like he was in 2022. On the other side, you have people who are so certain of their assessments that Jones is a terrible or "middling" QB that they insist there is no possibility Jones can have another successful season, despite the, at least on paper, improvement of his support.I think this is fair. I wanted McCarthy at 6. I feel Jones is an injury risk, yet, I have not seen the actual medicals and have not been present for his recovery. From an above orbit, risk management standpoint, having Jones replacement on hand seemed valid. That said, in this offense in particular, Jones can succeed. He can throw short passes to playmakers. The best Jones has had is crappy playmakers in a system designed to have them. Daboll/Kafka system doesn't work without YAC. I want to see the kid with an average OL and some playmakers. I think his body ends up betraying him. If Jones is healthy he will look good in this system I suspect with these playmakers.
