Pugh to be back 2024 ?

[killarich]

https://x.com/justinpugh/status/1768313560814477682?s=46&t=4UBQssq3DtM-8rvH6WpuWA


Reading in between the lines

[BluesCruz]

LOVE PUGH

cant wait see him heavier and with all rust off

[MightyGiants]

As a backup, I could think of worse.   He's an excellent locker room guy and he can be serviceable for short stretches

[nb587]

Pugh had no training camp pretty much coming off the couch and was starting on a badly coached crappy OL.  Of course he sucked.  I think he might actually contribute in a better situation

[DaveBrown74]

I don't have a problem with Pugh being on the roster at the right price, but I am not at all comfortable depending on him as a starter. At least not until I see him play well for a few games. He was brutal last year. I understand that people want to make excuses, and maybe they're valid, but no way I'd be comfortable with him as a starter at this point. I might be if I see him play solidly again, but based on what I know today, I wouldn't want him as anything more than a depth guy. If that.

[killarich]

Considering our signings and Neal still on the team I don't see him starting anywhere

But he would be a good plug and play for a game or 2 if injuries happen ..... could instantly line up anywhere on the line anywhere but center

Would love Pugh back

[AZGiantFan]

I'd rather have neither of them.

[Trench]

Our oline settled after his arrival as both Devito and TT had better starts than Jones had.

[Rosehill Jimmy]

At the right price.  I can see him as serving as a depth piece but I hope we can find someone better to start

[LennG]

 I would rather look elsewhere. He was just brutal last year and rust or not, it's time to call it a career.

[Stringer Bell]

I'd rather have neither of them.

Exactly. Pugh was awful last year. I appreciate that he's a good guy and teammate, but that's not enough. Signing guys because they are familiar has played a major part in this decade of awfulness.

We've brought in 3 guards and a tackle. Time for new blood. Signing Pugh would be a complete waste of a roster spot and cap space.

Same with OBJ. Don't want him anywhere near our locker room. And any time wasted on OBJ is less time and targets spent on Wan'dale, Hyatt, and hopefully Nabers.

Time to move on.

[DaveBrown74]

Exactly. Pugh was awful last year. I appreciate that he's a good guy and teammate, but that's not enough. Signing guys because they are familiar has played a major part in this decade of awfulness.

We've brought in 3 guards and a tackle. Time for new blood. Signing Pugh would be a complete waste of a roster spot and cap space.

Same with OBJ. Don't want him anywhere near our locker room. And any time wasted on OBJ is less time and targets spent on Wan'dale, Hyatt, and hopefully Nabers.

Time to move on.

Thank you. This "great locker room guy" stuff really has to stop. It's great when the player in question is actually a good player. But this is the same nonsense we heard all last summer for why Sterling Shepard should have a roster spot on the 2023 team and why cutting a much more useful player like Jamison Crowder to make the spot for him was a good idea. Shepard's being on the roster did absolutely nothing for the 2023 Giants. They were one of the worst teams in football, especially offensively. Let's not keep making this mistake over and over. It's a gruelingly competitive sports league, not a social club.