JJ McCarthy (could he be the Giants target in round one)?

[AZGiantFan]

If only! I've said that the Mara's are ultimately what drag the franchise down.

I've been drifting towards the assessment that Mara is Jerrah, without the flamboyance and, frankly, without the skills.  Say what you want about the Cowboys tendency to flame out, but at least they've been competitive enough to be in a position to flame out.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/danorlovsky7/status/1771185543927287961?s=20

[Philosophers]

https://x.com/danorlovsky7/status/1771185543927287961?s=20

Taking a very coachable player and giving him top notch coaching results in Dan's observation on the video.  Thanks Rich.

[Jolly Blue Giant]

I've been drifting towards the assessment that Mara is Jerrah, without the flamboyance and, frankly, without the skills.  Say what you want about the Cowboys tendency to flame out, but at least they've been competitive enough to be in a position to flame out.

Interesting point: Would a fan rather have a quality, entertaining, decent team that flames out every year at the end for decades (cheer all year, cry at the end)...or an up-and-down, feast-or-famine, stink-or-shine type of team that wins a Lombardi every decade (bitch all year, surprised some years and have a parade)?

As for me, I'll take the latter

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/realtannenbaum/status/1771144832263639427?s=46&t=1vcQIN8GqF5J2oLdxEVEJQ

[DaveBrown74]

https://x.com/realtannenbaum/status/1771144832263639427?s=46&t=1vcQIN8GqF5J2oLdxEVEJQ

Seems like a pretty routine play for any QB capable of being on an NFL roster.

If JJ McCarthy is a top five caliber pick, which he may well be, is that really the play you'd pick to prove that assertion?

[PSUBeirut]

https://x.com/realtannenbaum/status/1771144832263639427?s=46&t=1vcQIN8GqF5J2oLdxEVEJQ

I'm sorry but if that's the evidence count me out.  That is about as routine as a one-read play can get in that situation.  There was no reading of the defense on that play.  And to top it off the throw wasn't all that perfect either- he didn't lead the WR past the sticks.  If I was this guy I'd be embarrassed by this tweet.

And I'm no JJ hater.  I think he's actually gonna be one of the better QBs.  But not because of plays like this.

[sooners56]

Seems like a pretty routine play for any QB capable of being on an NFL roster.

If JJ McCarthy is a top five caliber pick, which he may well be, is that really the play you'd pick to prove that assertion?

My thoughts as well. Seems like that was the first read and the player was obviously about to be open. Easy read, easythrow and catch. I assure you my 13 year old could make that read and throw.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/nflrums/status/1771309930009542742?s=20

[MightyGiants]

Greg Cosell is a man whose opinion I highly value.  Greg never overstates and clearly states the limitations of his opinions.   Over the years I have seen him being proven correct more than he is proven wrong (which is rarely).  He does not seem high on JJ at all.


Is J.J. McCarthy's Draft Stock Rising Justified?
VIDEO 3/21/24

Greg Cosell explains why he isn't sure as to why there is an uptick in J.J. McCarthy's draft stock and why he is not a believer.


https://www.the33rdteam.com/is-j-j-mccarthys-draft-stock-rising-justified/

[DaveBrown74]

Interesting take on McCarthy from a former NFL scout:

https://twitter.com/firstroundmock/status/1771531489236127805?s=46&t=5ebj5eomvte9o41lpqwTkQ

[MightyGiants]

Interesting take on McCarthy from a former NFL scout:

https://twitter.com/firstroundmock/status/1771531489236127805?s=46&t=5ebj5eomvte9o41lpqwTkQ

I don't doubt his claim of 4 years working with the Jets, but frankly, I had a hard time taking him seriously after he made this comment:

"I can at least "comprehend" the strong feelings some people have about guys who have won the Heisman"

Of things that might be indicators of NFL success, winning the Heisman is not one of them.

[AZGiantFan]

Interesting point: Would a fan rather have a quality, entertaining, decent team that flames out every year at the end for decades (cheer all year, cry at the end)...or an up-and-down, feast-or-famine, stink-or-shine type of team that wins a Lombardi every decade (bitch all year, surprised some years and have a parade)?

As for me, I'll take the latter

However, I think it is fair to give Jerrah some credit for the Cowboys' relatively consistent competitiveness, while I think Mara has more to do with the famine years and very little to do with the occasional feast years.

[TONKA56]

Interesting point: Would a fan rather have a quality, entertaining, decent team that flames out every year at the end for decades (cheer all year, cry at the end)...or an up-and-down, feast-or-famine, stink-or-shine type of team that wins a Lombardi every decade (bitch all year, surprised some years and have a parade)?

As for me, I'll take the latter

We have this exact same conversation every three or four years.

[DaveBrown74]

Interesting point: Would a fan rather have a quality, entertaining, decent team that flames out every year at the end for decades (cheer all year, cry at the end)...or an up-and-down, feast-or-famine, stink-or-shine type of team that wins a Lombardi every decade (bitch all year, surprised some years and have a parade)?

As for me, I'll take the latter

Absolutely zero question I'd take the latter.