Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 09:38:33 AMTim,Speaking strictly about *our* conversations, I never said he was a bust but I also said that he has not shown any traces or tendencies of being a franchise QB. He's the very definition of an average QB who is not capable of putting his team on his back and dragging them to a victory. He can get 7-9 wins but doesn't offer anything to get 12-15. He is a step down from Ryan Tannehill but with legs.
You know I choose my words carefully. Do you think "a sense" is the same as knowing? When I use the words "a sense," one is less than certain. When one is less than certain, it should limit the strength of one's statements. I have always held the position that we can't be certain about DJ being a bust and that there is still some potential (admittedly a bit of a long shot at this point) that he can even prove to be a franchise QB.
Quote from: T200 on Today at 09:34:42 AMAnd this is where we have and continue to disagree. No need to rehash it. Just thought it was curious that you said "I believe even with disparate support, we can get a sense of how good another QB is", which is exactly why I and others have been saying.
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 09:30:59 AMTim,And this is where we have and continue to disagree. No need to rehash it. Just thought it was curious that you said "I believe even with disparate support, we can get a sense of how good another QB is", which is exactly why I and others have been saying.
I think there is a nuance on this issue. In a dysfunctional environment, every, or nearly every, QB will look bad. In a poor environment, people should factor in the poor environment (many do not).
More importantly, the ability to properly evaluate a quarterback is really the purview of that quarterback's coaching staff. As Daboll once said, people don't know the play calls. An apparent open receiver may be meaningless because they ran the wrong route. The fact of the matter is that we can get a sense of QB play by watching the games (or better yet, reviewing the all-22 with an informed eye), but no one outside the organization can evaluate with a strong degree of certainty (lacking the play calls and the QB's instructions).
Quote from: T200 on Today at 09:27:08 AMI have been saying this every single year Jones has been in the league: he can be evaluated despite what support he has or doesn't have around him. I got a lot of pushback from you and others saying that it was too difficult to evaluate him because of the lack of quality NFL support.
Seems to me the ability to evaluate a player is subjective.
Quote from: T200 on Today at 09:27:08 AMI have been saying this every single year Jones has been in the league: he can be evaluated despite what support he has or doesn't have around him. I got a lot of pushback from you and others saying that it was too difficult to evaluate him because of the lack of quality NFL support.
Seems to me the ability to evaluate a player is subjective.
Quote from: MightyGiants on Today at 09:19:32 AMI will admit that some of that is assuming that Jones is healthy and will get a chance to operate in at least a minimally supportive NFL quarterback environment this season. Plus, we have 2022, where DJ did operate in a less-than-ideal, but at least not dysfunctional (like 2023) environment. Much like Schoen and Daboll were able to evaluate Jones enough in 2022 to give him his big contract.I have been saying this every single year Jones has been in the league: he can be evaluated despite what support he has or doesn't have around him. I got a lot of pushback from you and others saying that it was too difficult to evaluate him because of the lack of quality NFL support.
Quote from: T200 on Today at 09:19:06 AMAs a fan, and in general, I try not to engage in it. It's self-defeatist, in my opinion.
I'm pretty sure all GMs and coaches know being second-guessed by fans and the media are a part of the job. They expect it and it probably doesn't phase them.