Big Blue Huddle

I voted 3rd stringer but why can't he become the next Brock Purdy?  Like a previous poster said, we deserve it.  Who knows really? 

Quote from: MightyGiants on October 25, 2023, 10:19:04 AMPurdy is an example of a QB who seems to possess more of the subtle tools than the obvious ones that jump off the screen at you on an eye test analysis.

Has Purdy begun to come back down to earth? or have teams finally figured him out?  He seems pretty below average his last 2 games.

Thomas - elite
JMS  -  Difference maker
Jackson  -  Can be a difference maker
Jones  -  TT has been doing well, no rush
Neal  -  Has been bad but definitely needs playing time so we can see what we really have

I think i figured out Neal's injury...his feelings are hurt, he's day to day   

Quote from: AZGiantFan on October 17, 2023, 08:24:39 PMMay he be their Golladay.

He may be their Golladay, but in on the field performance only.  We paid through the nose for Golladay 

Maybe Ronnie Barnes can suit up   

Who are the best current trade partners for Barkley?  Which teams are close to a championship and need a feature back or at least a complimentary back?

The point of this topic was't, "Would a top QB prospect want to play here"  It was about DJ's injury and if this gives Schoen an "out" or a built in excuse to draft a top QB.  He could easily say we would love DJ to be our QB until he retires but he has had multiple injuries and this latest one could be the most serious.  This is also a conversation that could be had with a top QB.  We liked the guy we had but unfortunately injuries forced our hand and we had to go back to the well.

Quote from: MightyGiants on October 11, 2023, 07:28:48 AMI am not sure you want to be the team that is in the market for a new QB because you ended the career of your last QB by failing to protect him.

I absolutely agree, but if your QB is hurt and is a hit away from possibly being done, you have to consider a replacement sooner rather than later.  This season has been a nightmare and some tough decisions are going to have to be made.

Jones has a neck injury and from what i'm hearing, it's a different one from the last one.  Does this give Schoen an easy out to draft a new QB and say it's safety for a possible career ending injury for Jones?  Seems like this could tie everything up with a neat little bow if they decide to move on from Jones.

That Patriots game was won because of Belichick's arrogance.  He saw the Giants were succeeding and rather than alter or make adjustments to their plan, he just kept doing the same thing believing his team was so superior that they would still win anyway.

when I look at what Dallas did with Elliot, I can see McCaffery.  When I look at our OL, I can see Bolles.  When I look at this list of 3 players, I just don't see Cunningham, especially if the other 2 are available as well.

I would have said no way the Giants pick an LB #1 but after hearing the love John Mara has for Flowers, LB may be their No. 1 priority   

I agree Todge, which is why I can't get too excited about this pick...not yet anyway.  I know that any player can be boom or bust but is it me or is this most evident with OLinemen?

I've heard mixed reviews on Ramczyk.  Is he just the best of a poor class or would he fare just as well in an OL stacked draft.

Either way, I'd be fine with this selection, just not doing cartwheels.