NFL QB Ranking by Tier

[Ed Vette]

I have some issues with this but mostly agree.

https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/2023-nfl-quarterback-rankings-by-tiers-trevor-lawrence-jalen-hurts-not-quite-in-elite-category-but-close/?

[ralphpal1]

Goff went to the superbowl
I don't care if cause it's the coach
He did it
When D Jones goes to the superbowl
Would it be only cause of daboll?
Alps Herbert choke a 27 pt lead away
Now he didn't have his wrs
Also the year before he didn't even make the playoffs and that is with a top 5 to 7 offense
Now you can blame the coach for that
It's a good list
But dak should be higher
He does make the playoffs which is hard no matter what team you are on

[kartanoman]

His subjective rationale is reasonable enough ... for now.

By his own admission, he infers a number of QBs will be moving up and down as the new season plays out.

In other words, just another moving target and it would be interesting to compare his list next year to this list and then draw some additional inferences.

Other than that, just your regular fluff piece any of us can, and have, done here on this board.

Peace!

[MightyGiants]

His subjective rationale is reasonable enough ... for now.

By his own admission, he infers a number of QBs will be moving up and down as the new season plays out.

In other words, just another moving target and it would be interesting to compare his list next year to this list and then draw some additional inferences.

Other than that, just your regular fluff piece any of us can, and have, done here on this board.

Peace!

This is why comparing QBs is a bit of a fool's errand, in my opinion.  Do we really think QB abilities vary that much season by season?