NFL Draft: Which Quarterback Is Statistically Superior?

[MightyGiants]

If you like statistics, this article is for you

https://fanduel.com/research/2024-nfl-draft-which-quarterback-is-statistically-superior

[MightyGiants]

Lance Zierlein
@LanceZierlein
I like to match up data points with tape study of that data to get context.  One of the data points that I consider very important is comp % out of scrambles.
According to PFF (comp% when scrambling):

Caleb 41.8%
Maye 36.8%
Daniels 46.7%
Nix 58.6%
Penix 23.3%
McCarthy 71.4%
11:14 AM · Feb 14, 2024
·


Lance Zierlein
@LanceZierlein
Here are the redzone pass numbers for top QBs according to PFF charting. Watched tape on all these throws as well for context:

Comp%/TD-INT

Nix 69.9% / 18-0
McCarthy 63.2% / 9-2
Caleb 63% / 12-0
Daniels 65% / 14-0
Penix 59.7% / 16-2
Maye 47.3% / 8-1
11:30 AM · Feb 14, 2024


https://x.com/LanceZierlein/status/1757804584309805438?s=20

[katkavage]

Going just on those stats, Maye looks like he doesn't belong in the top 5.