Big Blue Huddle

Could not disagree more. This is probably the best QB class since 2004. Caleb and Maye are fantastic. McCarthy and Daniels are very intriguing. And then there are other guys too. It is a great group.

Quote from: Stringer Bell on October 31, 2023, 07:04:25 PMThe QBs in this class are either overrated or correctly rated and sub-par. Not interested in any of them.

I don't want to even think about a non-QB in round 1. This deep needs to do whatever it takes to get their top guy at the position. Nothing they do in other places will matter if they don't.

Because they don't pay anything to their QB

Quote from: Philosophers on October 31, 2023, 02:58:26 PMHow can 49ers invest so much money in their DL?

I have Daniels and McCarthy tied for 3rd. I would stay away from Nix and Penix is a major healthy risk. I would trade up whatever I have to in order to take Drake Maye.

Giants should re-sign McKinney. He's been very solid of late. And he's young. Trading him just creates another hole to fill. Not sure you can fill it with what we'd be getting back.

I wish we'd trade Barkley. I have a feeling Schoen would if the decision was all his.

The defense is in pretty darn good shape. Of course things should be added. A competent QB that doesn't force the defense to stop the other team all day will do wonders. Find the QB. That is priority 1-10.

You want a guy to play with a serious neck injury? Are you for real.

Quote from: Dumpster Dan on October 29, 2023, 08:09:17 PMThe quickest way for me to forget today is try to think about next week

So how do all of you who wanted Devito out there feel about him being your starting QB next week

Its time for DJ to put his big boy pants on and get the hell out on the field and show us what he is made of

Those Of you who have clamored for Devito should feel real good about him starting when we have a coach who showed the world that he has no confidence in him

Dumpster Dan

He called a very good game last week. It wasn't his fault Barkley fumbled or that Gano missed kicks.

Sure fire the OC because he couldn't do anything because the third string QB some of you wanted to start didn't even know how to call a play out without reading his wristband. He couldn't even throw the ball past the LOS. But that's the guy you folks said was better than Tyrod Taylor. This place sounds like BBI today. I think I'm gonna stay away.

He's been very good since week 3. But no one here wants to admit it because they'd rather be right.

Quote from: Ed Vette on October 29, 2023, 04:08:49 PMBreakout game. Give him some love. He earned it.

Do anything you need to do to get a franchise QB. Shore up the OL in free agency. Do those two things and the team will be a lot better. QB means the most of any position in sports. Do whatever you have to do to find your guy.

Quote from: Philosophers on October 29, 2023, 04:38:00 PMOk so Giants are near season halfway mark.  Have not been able to score or throw the ball so far this season.  Pass blocking has been abysmal.

The Defense looked mediocre initially but last few games has come on with play of Dex and Thibs.

What do you guys think the offseason priorities need to be at this point of the season?

Defense has improved a ton from early in the year. What do you expect with this banged up OL and a third string QB who has no clue what he's doing. Give me a break.

I don't care. I'm going to say. This is dumb. Daboll coached the game today the exact correct way for the circumstances. Daboll is a good coach. He is incredibly well respected. Firing him would compeletely idiotic.

He obviously reinjured it. He almost played in Arizona. Reinjuries of hamstrings is not uncommon at all.

Quote from: spiderblue43 on October 28, 2023, 02:06:08 PMI've never seen a hamstring hamstrung a OL like Thomas. He's still very young and should recover faster than this IMHO. 

 You could can rely on the much older Lane Johnson to suit up always unless he's missing a body part.

By simply adding a void year to a contract that has a signing bonus on it.