Big Blue Huddle

Coaches divided, players divided and we have our answer on why the Giants have sucked for so long.

Goff
Jackson
Allen
.

Goff is super efficient. Jackson just keeps producing. Special long throws by Allen even though his WRs dropped them.

Bucs-Lions game for me. I want one of those teams to win Super Bowl. Bucs because of Baker and Lions because one of my best friends is a die hard Lions fan. Lions fans deserve this for sticking with them for so long. Bills would be my 3rd choice for Super Bowl champs.

Baker Mayfield and the Bucs are rolling the Eagles! Love it

If all that is true, the answer is a no brainer! Cut him and save $12 million.

Sounds like the Giants need a new coach! I'd be ok with starting over at GM and coach. Daboll is a bad leader and Schoen can't draft

For starters, they almost, if not always, have a great Oline. Not just good but great. 2nd they only have 1 Super Bowl victory with Rodgers. Love may get one eventually but I doubt it is this year.

Quote from: 4 Aces on January 15, 2024, 09:54:04 AMIs this question in relation to Brock Bowers?

Curious to get others' opinion on him. I do not see a special player but I appear to be the only one. I'd be dubious spending a top 10 pick on him. He's listed at 6'4" but I'll be curious to see his measurements at the Combine.

To me, he looks like kind of a run-of-the-mill move TE in the NFL.

The question basically boils down to would you rather have a stud WR or a stud TE. I believe both will be available at pick 6 (Nabers, Odunze, etc) or Bowers. I would pick the WR, Nabers or Odunze, over the stud TE (Bowers)

Quote from: TDToomer on January 14, 2024, 04:51:16 PMHow does asking people to vote between two players who were drafted 10+ years ago, weren't even in the same draft class, relative to our 2024 draft?

You may just want to skip over this post and find a post more to your liking. But anyways, I thought it was obvious but I guess not. OBJ and Kelce are known commodities which is why I used them as examples. I feel like Nabers is an OBJ clone and Bowers is a Kelce clone.

Quote from: TDToomer on January 14, 2024, 03:43:38 PMWhat's with all the silly meaningless polls?

This is a Giants board where we discuss Giants topics. The Giants are not in the playoffs so the draft is my topic of interest. I am just trying to gauge the fans thoughts on value of elite WR vs Elite Te. The Giants will be in a spot to grab the Elite WR or elite TE.

The Giants have the 6th pick in this years draft. Let's say all QBs are gone and no other offensive or defensive player can be drafted at pick 6. Which player do you draft at pick 6?  I ask because Malik Nabers and Brock Bowers could be options at 6 and imo, are favorable to the players mentioned. Which one would offer the best ROI for the Giants as they are now?

Safe to say PFF didn't like Schoens 2 drafts! I'd have to say I agree with PFF. The drafts just haven't been good enough.  I won't fault Schoen for the Thibs and Neal pick as those seemed like grand slam picks. GM is a tough job it seems.

Super accurate easy looking TD pass by Stroud to Schultz

Seems like a good enough hire to me for the benefit of the secondary! However, like Elvis mentioned what would the hire mean for Kayvon and the rest of the pass rush?

Quote from: Jolly Blue Giant on January 13, 2024, 12:50:25 PMMy biggest disappointments for the season came from Waller, Campbell, JMS, and Neal. I don't see how Banks was a season-long GOAT 

Waller and Neal were hit by injuries that killed their season, but Parris Campbell was supposed to bring a new dimension - I had great hopes for him...don't know what happened there...it's as if he wasn't even on the team

JMS is a rookie sandwiched between two below average guards, so I give him a pass. He'll become the stud we expected...IMO

I never understood why people thought Pareis Campbell would bring anything to this Giants offense when in the 4 prior years with the Colts, he did absolutely nothing. In those 4 years, he only had one season over 162 yards. Yes, 1 season over 162 yards receiving yet Giants fans thought he was going to do something on a much worse offensive unit 🤷🏼�♂️