In Retrospect

[Philosophers]

Curious what you think now.

[Bob In PA]

Nix is "too old" IMO (for high 1st-round) and Penix & McCarthy are still "heck no's" (as high 1st-rounders).

Odunze I still like a lot, and believed then (and now) that he was likely the better choice for Jones.

But none of them is the player Nabers has shown himself to be. I had more doubts about him than I posted here, but he has answered all of them (except for my view that he might not fit in with the Giants, NY, NJ, Mara, etc., any better than OBJ did... for similar, if not the same, reasons).

Bob

[T200]

Not having seen JJ or Penix play yet, I can't suggest that we should have gone with one of them.

It's still his rookie campaign so I won't second-guess the pick... yet.

[MightyGiants]

I have to say Bo Nix, knowing full well I would be greatly disappointed because the Giants' coaching staff and talent levels are inferior to the Broncos.  So Nix would play no where near as well for the Giants

[katkavage]

They are 2-10 with Nabers and still searching for a QB. Without the QB the receiver is meaningless. They blew it by not taking a QB.

[sooners56]

JJ McCarthy for me. I think he has the potential to be the best QB out of that draft. The injury delays us all seeing that.