5 top Giants WRs of all Time?

[Trench]

Nobody changed our offense more than Plax. Nobody.

Eli wouldn't make the Hall of Fame without him.

[LennG]

Nobody changed our offense more than Plax. Nobody.

Eli wouldn't make the Hall of Fame without him.

I can't argue that Plax wasn't a great WR, but he was only a Giants for what 3-4 years. Sure he made his mark and yes he made Eli look like a great QB as he was able to catch all those overthrown balls that Eli always made, but I forgot to mention a receiver, more of a TE who should be ranked right up there, Bob Tucker, who, for many years was our only receiver who could catch. I believe he led the league once in receptions yet no on even considers him as one of the greats.

[Trench]

I know he wasn't a superstar but one of the most sure handed and reliable WR and perhaps our best slot possesion guy was Phil McConkey. He seemed to always run his route past the marker - unlike WanDale who has a terrible sense of where he needs to be