33rd team does a 2024 redraft

[MightyGiants]

A bit early, but not much going on

[T200]

I mean, did they provide any rationale for this list?

[MightyGiants]

I mean, did they provide any rationale for this list?

https://www.the33rdteam.com/re-drafting-2024-nfl-draft-as-rookie-seasons-near-end/

[T200]

Interesting how even with the redraft and knowing the Giants dumped Jones, they still had the Giants picking a receiver, once again passing on Nix, Penix, and McCarthy.

[Bob In PA]

I mean, did they provide any rationale for this list?

Tim: I'll provide one... waste our time with some Monday-morning quarterbacking of their own. Bob

[T200]

Tim: I'll provide one... waste our time with some Monday-morning quarterbacking of their own. Bob

 

I like that! 

[MightyGiants]

Interesting how even with the redraft and knowing the Giants dumped Jones, they still had the Giants picking a receiver, once again passing on Nix, Penix, and McCarthy.

I think the Giants were in a bit of a catch-22.  I believe that the better the pillars of support, the better the chances of successfully developing a drafted QB prospect. 

That's why they explained their decision to pass on a QB with:

They'll still need to figure out the quarterback position, but whoever they would have taken at quarterback in this redraft would have had no one to throw to.

[MightyGiants]

Tim: I'll provide one... waste our time with some Monday-morning quarterbacking of their own. Bob

Bob,

Still, this is a rare occasion where the Monday-morning quarterbacking worked in the Giants' favor.  NYG drafted Nabers, who would have gone two picks earlier in the redraft.  I would call that a "win"

[T200]

Bob,

Still, this is a rare occasion where the Monday-morning quarterbacking worked in the Giants' favor.  NYG drafted Nabers, who would have gone two picks earlier in the redraft.  I would call that a "win"

I give it zero credence. It's a different version of someone else's opinion.

I think it was a weird exercise, or as Bob said it much better, a waste of time.

[Bob In PA]

Bob,

Still, this is a rare occasion where the Monday-morning quarterbacking worked in the Giants' favor.  NYG drafted Nabers, who would have gone two picks earlier in the redraft.  I would call that a "win"

Rich: I did notice that and would only amend your correct statement by adding "a win THUS FAR."  Bob

[Painter]

As Rich said: "A bit early, but not much going on" That's sorta the case, I suppose. In any event, I have to wonder whether or not this eyeball-seeking re-Draft actually assumed the absence of Daniel Jones, wishful thinking/second-guessing aside?

But does it really matter as it hasn't gotten as much interest here as the so called, 33rdteam may have hoped for. Qui s'en soucie?

Cheers!

[brownelvis54]

A bit early, but not much going on

Silly

[TDToomer]

Dru Phillips moves up to 22nd but the consensus here is that he can only play Slot Corner and we need to reach yet again for another CB.

[PSUBeirut]

Not having the Giants draft Nix in this fantasy scenario is preposterous, in my opinion.  The guy can clearly play.