We Need A QB But…

[Philosophers]

Dont stretch in draft for a QB just because of need.  If we draft 5th and we dont like the QB options, then draft BPA.  We need more talent.  We get the QB when one is in the right position.

[T200]

Look no further than this past draft. McCarthy, Nix and Penix were all there. Schoen and Daboll had certain criteria for the QB they wanted and those three didn't fit the bill. That tells me they know what they want and will not do as you said; grab a guy just to have a guy.

Now, one of those three may turn out to be great. But that's how it goes in the draft. I certainly won't beat them up for it.

[Philosophers]

Look no further than this past draft. McCarthy, Nix and Penix were all there. Schoen and Daboll had certain criteria for the QB they wanted and those three didn't fit the bill. That tells me they know what they want and will not do as you said; grab a guy just to have a guy.

Now, one of those three may turn out to be great. But that's how it goes in the draft. I certainly won't beat them up for it.

I agree with you.  They didnt make the Giants cut.  As a result we got a stud WR.  If in 2025 we dont get a QB the. Let's get a stud OT, DT, etc.

[MightyGiants]

for what it's worth, and the college prospects still have time to put more on tape (especially in college playoff games), Dane Brugler said if you combined this QB class with last year, the top 4 would all come from last year (Williams, Daniels, Maye, and JJ) and the top QBs in this class are on par with Penix and Nix.

[Gmo11]

for what it's worth, and the college prospects still have time to put more on tape (especially in college playoff games), Dane Brugler said if you combined this QB class with last year, the top 4 would all come from last year (Williams, Daniels, Maye, and JJ) and the top QBs in this class are on par with Penix and Nix.

So far I agree.  I was very low on Maye (not looking good for me on that one) but I also had JJ in that same tier with the other 3.  And that's where I think Cam + Sanders end up when it's all said and done.  Which is plenty good enough to win with.  We just need whoever they take to not be an enormous bust. 

[MightyGiants]

So far I agree.  I was very low on Maye (not looking good for me on that one) but I also had JJ in that same tier with the other 3.  And that's where I think Cam + Sanders end up when it's all said and done.  Which is plenty good enough to win with.  We just need whoever they take to not be an enormous bust. 

Sadly, JJ's ACL short-circuited using him as a point of comparison (since we didn't get to see how he did in the NFL this season)