JJ McCarthy (could he be the Giants target in round one)?

[EliWasrobbed]

You can put a film study like that on every QB and every player.  They all make mistakes in a game so highlighting it offers nothing.  Do you think Caleb Williams does not ever miss a read or not focus one place when he should throw somewhere else.  Of course he soes.  What's great about that video is that even on plays where he could have gone to one player and threw it or ran it, he still made a big play.

ok confirmed you are a JJ guy instead of Drake, makes sense now

[EliWasrobbed]

26 pages of nonsense?

Very mature repsonse

you would know a LOT about maturity given your attacks on me.

[Philosophers]

ok confirmed you are a JJ guy instead of Drake, makes sense now

What did I write that concludes that?

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/lancezierlein/status/1769386510413898011?s=46&t=1vcQIN8GqF5J2oLdxEVEJQ

[Philosophers]

Given that JJ is the most polarizing prospect in this board, I probably hope the Giants don't draft him. 

[DaveBrown74]

Given that JJ is the most polarizing prospect in this board, I probably hope the Giants don't draft him. 

If he's good, I don't know why a little pre-draft controversy will matter. I'm sure Texans fans had some disagreements about Stroud last spring/summer. I doubt they do now.

[Philosophers]

If he's good, I don't know why a little pre-draft controversy will matter. I'm sure Texans fans had some disagreements about Stroud last spring/summer. I doubt they do now.

Conclusions here are formed by many.

Stroud had nowhere near the doubt.

Happy to get Nabers and go from there.

[DaveBrown74]

Conclusions here are formed by many.

Stroud had nowhere near the doubt.

Happy to get Nabers and go from there.

I suppose. I certainly haven't formed any myself.

For me, I just want the team to start winning. In other words, I want them to get the best possible players and develop them well. I don't really care that much what other fans think or say before the draft. There is always going to be noise. There will always be mixed opinions. And yes, there will always be fans who think they themselves know more than NFL front offices. It's just part of what the NFL offseason is always about, every year. It is what it is.

[y_so_blu]

Given that JJ is the most polarizing prospect in this board, I probably hope the Giants don't draft him. 

This board could polarize itself over how to hang toilet paper.

McCarthy is much more promising than anything we have now at QB, and I'll be excited if we get him.

[Philosophers]

This board could polarize itself over how to hang toilet paper.

McCarthy is much more promising than anything we have now at QB, and I'll be excited if we get him.

Ha Ha tough to disagree with that.

[MightyGiants]

Given that JJ is the most polarizing prospect in this board, I probably hope the Giants don't draft him. 

I think you are seeing the difference between production scouting and trait scouting.

[AZGiantFan]

No, no, no.  Not roulette, craps.  LOL

[Philosophers]

I hate the idea of leaving topflight talent at other positions available to draft a QB who does not get it done.  They need to nail the evaluation.

[DaveBrown74]

I hate the idea of leaving topflight talent at other positions available to draft a QB who does not get it done.  They need to nail the evaluation.

I agree. We've done it before. Can't do it again.

[GordonGekko80]

JJ McCarthy will be drafted by NE as the #3 pick in the draft.

The first 3 QBs in the draft will go in these spots. I am pretty sure.

I don't think the Giants will be in a position to draft a quality QB at #6 without reaching (and even JJ might be a reach at #6 imho).