The more I hear the more the Giants option at 6 will be

[Painter]

In no way was that meant as criticism of your views and selections, Rich. I certainly wasn't editing your choices. Quite the contrary, I was reminding all of us as to why we call it the Silly Season, which probably was unnecessary and perhaps even tedious. I shouldn't have commented, I guess.

Cheers!

[katkavage]

In no way was that meant as criticism of your views and selections, Rich. I certainly wasn't editing your choices. Quite the contrary, I was reminding all of us as to why we call it the Silly Season, which probably was unnecessary and perhaps even tedious. I shouldn't have commented, I guess.

Cheers!

Now we need Painter to start a blog: Mocking the Mocks

[Gman329]

If we pick McCarthy at 6, I will be needing a new TV.  I can't even imagine that's a consideration. 

[President Rick]

IF mccarthy is qb#4 in this draft, then where does that place him if you are committed to taking the best player available [albeit in a position of some to high need] with pick #6??????????????

that sounds like a real long shot IMO.  I'd go OL or a top 3 WR at pick 6 and look for a backup qb in FA or in round 2.

[Stringer Bell]

LT Joe Alt
WR Rome Odunze
QB J.J. McCarthy


I believe QBs Williams, Maye, and Daniels go in some order 1,2, and 3

I think WR Harrison and WR Nabers go in some order 4 and 5


So who do you take?

In this scenario with Nabers gone, I wonder if the Bears would be interested in trading up from #9 to land Odunze tk pair with their new QB.

I think if Nabers falls to the Giants, the Bears would then roll the dice in Odunze dropping to them. But if not, they might be interested.

We'd pick up an extra 3rd rounder (and maybe a 5th?), and still be in a position to land McCarthy, Alt, Turner.

[Painter]

Now we need Painter to start a blog: Mocking the Mocks

Not a bad idea. How about I start with you...I mean yours. It certainly wouldn't take much time or imagination.

Cheers!

[gregf]

LT Joe Alt
WR Rome Odunze
QB J.J. McCarthy


I believe QBs Williams, Maye, and Daniels go in some order 1,2, and 3

I think WR Harrison and WR Nabers go in some order 4 and 5


So who do you take?

All solid options. I like Alt, but that really depends if new o line coach feels Neal is better at guard.  I'd love a QB,but the 4th QB at 6 -You'd better be sold he is an upgrade. At this point, I think it's WR, with o line help in rd 2 and FA. A QB is definitely in play to move back into rd 1 or rd 2.

[katkavage]

Not a bad idea. How about I start with you...I mean yours. It certainly wouldn't take much time or imagination.

Cheers!

If I ever in my life made/make a mock draft you can have at it. I'd welcome your crank, after all this is supposed to be fun, an escape. Nothing to take too seriously. At least I don't and would recommend others take a breath which is why I suggested mocking the Mocks.

[Philosophers]

If we're not drafting a QB and Nabers is there at 6, he'd be tough to pass up. Odunze is impressive for sure and does bring certain attributes to the table that Nabers doesn't, but the same can be said about Nabers. His tape really pops for me and has all year. The guy is flat out explosive and can seriously separate. His moves in the open field are also second to none.

What is Nabers maturity level?  Anyone read anything tangible about it?

I dont want partying on a boat in Miami 2.0

[DaveBrown74]

What is Nabers maturity level?  Anyone read anything tangible about it?

I dont want partying on a boat in Miami 2.0

Is there any concrete, legitimately sourced evidence that he has displayed immaturity or an otherwise bad attitude?

[katkavage]

Is there any concrete, legitimately sourced evidence that he has displayed immaturity or an otherwise bad attitude?

It's the nonsense season.

[jimc]

IF mccarthy is qb#4 in this draft, then where does that place him if you are committed to taking the best player available [albeit in a position of some to high need] with pick #6??????????????

that sounds like a real long shot IMO.  I'd go OL or a top 3 WR at pick 6 and look for a backup qb in FA or in round 2.

I agree, except I wouldn't take o lineman at 6 unless an it was a lt. I want an impact player at 6. WR, Edge, CB....

[DaveBrown74]

It's the nonsense season.

Well I have no idea. Maybe there's something I missed on him. That's totally possible. Hence why I asked.

I personally haven't seen anything like that myself on him though. And I'm not just going to stereotype the guy as some thug or diva solely because he went to LSU without there being any actual red flags from a credible source.

[Jclayton92]

All solid options. I like Alt, but that really depends if new o line coach feels Neal is better at guard.  I'd love a QB,but the 4th QB at 6 -You'd better be sold he is an upgrade. At this point, I think it's WR, with o line help in rd 2 and FA. A QB is definitely in play to move back into rd 1 or rd 2.

From everything I've heard, the Giants have spoken to a ton of guards and tackles agents at the combine. All seem to be mid level signings were they can bring in 2 guards and a swing to add depth and competition hopefully finalizing the line.

[Philosophers]

Is there any concrete, legitimately sourced evidence that he has displayed immaturity or an otherwise bad attitude?

I am asking because only thing I read about him is what everyone keeps repeating which is explosive.

How does he train?  What do coaches say about his dedication in practices?  Does he stay around for extra passing sessions?  Out of practice, what's he doing?

Would like to understand more about him.  I'm not doubting him if that's what you were concluding.