Rate the Brian Burns trade

[uconnjack8]

Rams have sort of trailblazed a different blueprint for building a championship roster.  They have been successful with the big trades they made. 

We'll see how resilient they are when they try and move on from a top 5 all-time DT.  They impressively built a solid back end of their defense last year.

[Painter]

Why would anyone here assume to be equipped to make such judgements? I know, we yack for the sake of it but still... all that really matters is that whatever we think won't matter in the least as we know how the Giants have answered the question. So, I suppose what we are really doing is that which we thrive upon and do best which is second-guessing the Giants as a whole.

So, wouldn't be more to the point to rate the Giants chances of finishing next to last rather than last in the Division with or without their having made the Brian Burns trade?

Cheers!

[Stringer Bell]

"Hey guys, the Giants made a move. Let's discuss on this message board."

"What a wayward folly of dullards to deign an astute observation whence it's sourced from the annals of mediocrity. Ergo, consider your poppycock dalliances to be yet another weary slight to wisdom and honor."

Rinse. Repeat.

[Painter]

"Hey guys, the Giants made a move. Let's discuss on this message board."

"What a wayward folly of dullards to deign an astute observation whence it's sourced from the annals of mediocrity. Ergo, consider your poppycock dalliances to be yet another weary slight to wisdom and honor."

Rinse. Repeat.

Well done. You took the words right out of my mouth. I couldn't have said it any better although perhaps you were a tad too harsh. In any case, glad we see it the same way.

Cheers!

[TONKA56]

I am pretty down on this trade myself.

The Giants gave Burns the sort of contract that would have allowed the Giants to sign one of the free-agent edge rushers and saved the draft capital they spent.

As Mike Lombardi said, Brian Burns is not a blue-chip player.  There can be an argument made that he is a red chipper.  The problem, in my eye, is that the Giants spent cap and draft capital like Brian Burns was a blue-chip player, and he hasn't shown that in his 4 years in the league.

The Giants have a pretty poor track record of signing edge rushers as free agents. Overwhelmingly our best edge players have been drafted.

[uconnjack8]

Hopefully he plays like the company he keeps in salary

[Doc16LT56]

The Giants have a pretty poor track record of signing edge rushers as free agents. Overwhelmingly our best edge players have been drafted.

The Giants traded a 2nd round pick for Burns. They weren't going to use the 6th overall pick on an edge rusher this year, so they would've been throwing another dart at 2nd round or later edge rushers which they haven't had much success with the last 20+ years. The last time they hit on one was Osi in 2003.

2004: Reggie Torbor, 4th round
2009: Clint Sintim, 2nd round
2010: Adrian Tracey. 6th round
2013: Damontre Moore, 3rd round
2014: Devon Kennard, 6th round
2015: Odigi, 3rd round
2018: Lorenzo Carter, 3rd round
2019: Oshane Ximines, 3rd round
2021: Azeez Ojulari, 2nd round
2021: Elerson Smith, 4th round

Brian Burns for a 2nd round pick instantly gives the team an alpha edge rusher and teams up perfectly with Thibs and Dex. It was the right move at the right time.

[TONKA56]

The Giants traded a 2nd round pick for Burns. They weren't going to use the 6th overall pick on an edge rusher this year, so they would've been throwing another dart at 2nd round or later edge rushers which they haven't had much success with the last 20+ years. The last time they hit on one was Osi in 2003.

2004: Reggie Torbor, 4th round
2009: Clint Sintim, 2nd round
2010: Adrian Tracey. 6th round
2013: Damontre Moore, 3rd round
2014: Devon Kennard, 6th round
2015: Odigi, 3rd round
2018: Lorenzo Carter, 3rd round
2019: Oshane Ximines, 3rd round
2021: Azeez Ojulari, 2nd round
2021: Elerson Smith, 4th round

Brian Burns for a 2nd round pick instantly gives the team an alpha edge rusher and teams up perfectly with Thibs and Dex. It was the right move at the right time.

Nothing I stated really has anything to do specifically with the Burns deal, to which I am completely indifferent. I just hope it's not reminiscent of Kenny Holmes, LaVar Arrington, or Olivier Vernon.

[Doc16LT56]

Nothing I stated really has anything to do specifically with the Burns deal, to which I am completely indifferent. I just hope it's not reminiscent of Kenny Holmes, LaVar Arrington, or Olivier Vernon.

No, you said their best edge players have been drafted. If you're referring to JPP, Kiwi, and Thibs, those were all 1st round picks. What I tried to share in my post is their track record after the 1st round is not good. That's why I think the Burns trade makes so much sense.

[TONKA56]

No, you said their best edge players have been drafted. If you're referring to JPP, Kiwi, and Thibs, those were all 1st round picks. What I tried to share in my post is their track record after the 1st round is not good. That's why I think the Burns trade makes so much sense.

Well, here we are. Hope Burns improves, but right now this is looking like a bad deal.

[Doc16LT56]

Well, here we are. Hope Burns improves, but right now this is looking like a bad deal.

Really? The Giants defense was 27th last year and is currently 12th. Burns is a big part of the improvement.

He hasn't dominated as an edge rusher but he hasn't been a problem either.

https://x.com/Anthony_Rivardo/status/1841500611663003655?t=mS5X5DtMvw_BG3JSwIFxdQ&s=19

[TONKA56]

Really? The Giants defense was 27th last year and is currently 12th. Burns is a big part of the improvement.

He hasn't dominated as an edge rusher but he hasn't been a problem either.

https://x.com/Anthony_Rivardo/status/1841500611663003655?t=mS5X5DtMvw_BG3JSwIFxdQ&s=19

https://youtu.be/xZs0p1qsVFU?si=jaMDx1MswY60zBha

[Doc16LT56]

https://youtu.be/xZs0p1qsVFU?si=jaMDx1MswY60zBha

Well, here we are. Hope Burns improves, but right now this is looking like a bad deal.

I'm glad you're in record now stating the Burns deal is a bad one. I'm curious how you'd have preferred to use the resources they used on Burns.

[TONKA56]

I'm glad you're in record now stating the Burns deal is a bad one. I'm curious how you'd have preferred to use the resources they used on Burns.

What I said was that it appears to me that the Giants track record of signing free agent edge rushers was unimpressive and I hoped Burns wasn't a continuation of that perception. That's all I'm owning. 

[Doc16LT56]

What I said was that it appears to me that the Giants track record of signing free agent edge rushers was unimpressive and I hoped Burns wasn't a continuation of that perception. That's all I'm owning. 

Today you wrote: "this is looking like a bad deal."

Four games in and you were ready to make that proclamation. So own it.