Giants Should Not Draft A QB In First Round

[katkavage]

I will add this, I did some real digging.  If the Giants don't grab a QB in round one, it seems highly unlikely they will find a potential (even developmental) starting QB in day 2 or 3.  Maybe Spencer Rattler, but he seems like a long shot to become a top 10 QB.  I suspect his ceiling is starter a team where the team is constantly looking to upgrade the position.

I will add this, I did some real digging.  If the Giants don't grab a QB in round one, it seems highly unlikely they will find a potential (even developmental) starting QB in day 2 or 3.  Maybe Spencer Rattler, but he seems like a long shot to become a top 10 QB.  I suspect his ceiling is starter a team where the team is constantly looking to upgrade the position.

I agree. The only one I would take is Penix. In fact, Minnesota would be stupid to trade up for McCarthy. Penix is the perfect fit for Minnesota. They have many pieces in place, including a great WR. He is NFL ready where McCarthy might need a year or two of development. The Vikings could get Penix easily at their pick and they have another pick in the first round that could fill a need.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/clt_ny/status/1772386758799278125?s=20