Is it worth to keep jones next year

[coggs]

Well, according to his coaches, he is excellent at reading defenses. I'm no coach and I have no inside information, but I believe his QB coaches know whether or not DJ understands and reads defenses

What they really think and what they say publicly can be 2 very different things.

[Gmo11]

What they really think and what they say publicly can be 2 very different things.

I have absolutely no doubts that in the film room he knows exactly what to do and how to do it.

It's when he gets out on the field where the trouble occurs. He's certainly not the first and won't be the last QB with this infliction. But it doesn't appear to be curable.

[Doc16LT56]

I have absolutely no doubts that in the film room he knows exactly what to do and how to do it.

It's when he gets out on the field where the trouble occurs. He's certainly not the first and won't be the last QB with this infliction. But it doesn't appear to be curable.

Right. Classroom intelligence isn't the same as fast processing during a play.

I think a good analogy is how some chess grand masters struggle at speed chess. If you give them time, they can anticipate every possible move, but when the pressure of the clock is added they become one dimensional.

[AZGiantFan]

Right. Classroom intelligence isn't the same as fast processing during a play.

I think a good analogy is how some chess grand masters struggle at speed chess. If you give them time, they can anticipate every possible move, but when the pressure of the clock is added they become one dimensional.

In golf they call this being a Ranger Rick, who can't take the practice range out to the course.  It also makes those blackboard sessions at the combine seem a little over-rated in their importance.

[Uncle Mickey]

Right. Classroom intelligence isn't the same as fast processing during a play.

I think a good analogy is how some chess grand masters struggle at speed chess. If you give them time, they can anticipate every possible move, but when the pressure of the clock is added they become one dimensional.

Great analogy Doc. For a slower processing QB the simpler the reads the faster they can progress. Jones is defintely not élite in this category but he can be good potentially in a simpler system.

[Hadron]

Didn't Jones play like one preseason series last year?

Again, this unwavering faith in a QB who simply lacks the chops to be a starter in this league.

Does he have the athleticism and work ethic? Sure. He's just missing that processing ability that starters possess. Davis Webb is a guy that had a lot of positive factors save for one: processing the field.

[MightyGiants]

Again, this unwavering faith in a QB who simply lacks the chops to be a starter in this league.

Does he have the athleticism and work ethic? Sure. He's just missing that processing ability that starters possess. Davis Webb is a guy that had a lot of positive factors save for one: processing the field.

What "faith" are you referring to?  I simply felt it was inappropriate to say the guy who got screwed over royally by NYG (even the owner admits it) should be accused of "leaching" off the team.