Schoen's comment about a $40 million dollar QB handing off

[LennG]

Respectfully, that should be the LAST thing on his mind.
Giants fans have always been about one thing: WINNING.
I'm tired of being a last place team!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

What about the owners,?

Can we say for certanty that that has always been the case.

[andrew_nyGiants]

What about the owners,?

Can we say for certanty that that has always been the case.

Are you questioning whether Mara is about winning? Or is it about his lack of competence making the right decisions?

I lean toward the latter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[MrGap92]

Respectfully, that should be the LAST thing on his mind.
Giants fans have always been about one thing: WINNING.
I'm tired of being a last place team!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

He is an owner, not a fan, this is his business, not a team he roots for, as well as his livelihood.

Not the same

He does not meddle the way so many here think he does, if we didn't have a garbage QB, we would not be having this discussion.

[andrew_nyGiants]

He is an owner, not a fan, this is his business, not a team he roots for, as well as his livelihood.

Not the same

He does not meddle the way so many here think he does, if we didn't have a garbage QB, we would not be having this discussion.

So you don't think he had ANY influence in signing that "garbage QB" to that massive extension?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[MrGap92]

So you don't think he had ANY influence in signing that "garbage QB" to that massive extension?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

I think the options available, on paper, were not great or better than what they had, so they didn't have much choice, which is why they constructed the contract how they did.

[andrew_nyGiants]

I think the options available, on paper, were not great or better than what they had, so they didn't have much choice, which is why they constructed the contract how they did.

So you're saying they had no choice but to extend him even though they weren't 100% sold on him based on the market that year?

That's kind of short-sighted don't you think?

Building a great roster is a process, and that signing IMO, retarded their progress.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[MightyGiants]

What about the owners,?

Can we say for certanty that that has always been the case.

Giants owner John Mara seemingly knocks over trash cans in frustration
By Ryan Dunleavy
Published Sep. 26, 2021

https://nypost.com/2021/09/26/giants-owner-john-mara-seemingly-knocks-over-trash-can/

[andrew_nyGiants]

Giants owner John Mara seemingly knocks over trash cans in frustration
By Ryan Dunleavy
Published Sep. 26, 2021

https://nypost.com/2021/09/26/giants-owner-john-mara-seemingly-knocks-over-trash-can/

Like I said, he tends to react from his emotions.
It's okay to care, it's better to make solid decisions.
Hire the right people and let them do their job.

Those who get on Daboll for making poor decisions, should also get on Mara for the same.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[TDToomer]

Never forget

[PSUBeirut]

Having Barkley doesnt add a nickel of revenue to the Giants.  Tickets are still sold.  Jersey sales are shared league wide.  Having him go to another team probably added money to the giants share of that revenue.  Giants fans already have Barkley jerseys.  A lot more Eagles fans went out and bought his jersey than Giants fans would.

Agreed.  I think the reason Mara didn't want to lose Barkley was simply personal- he like him as a person, a team captain, and a face of the franchise.  I don't think it had anything to do with putting butts in the seats.  Winning teams do that, not running backs.

[Bob In PA]

That military-like way of thinking is becoming less and less the norm in the workplace.

coggs: Agree with it as written, but you didn't say whether you like or dislike the "less and less" part. Bob

[todge]

Andrew,

Schoen said this in the middle of a strategy meeting.  HBO recorded hundreds of hours of tape, and there was no way Joe Schoen knew that particular comment would make the show.  If it was a shot at his boss, it was a poorly timed and executed shot, in my opinion.

It was my understanding the Giants had final veto power over any content aired in Hard Knocks. Am I wrong? Regardless, Schoen said a lot of things on that show that shouldn't have been aired.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[coggs]

I have been researching.  If Barkley increases attendance, the team's revenue will increase via concessions.  I am not 100% sure, but I believe teams also make more money for team merch sold in their stadium stores (which, again, is fan-driven).  Ticket sales are 60/40 for the home team.  NFL teams keep all the suites and sponsor money (Which a marketable name like Barkley will help).

The NFL has marketing deals with merchandising companies, and that money is shared.

How many people do you think are going to games and buying Barkley jerseys?  If they are buying a jersey at the game, they are buying whichever current player they want now.

Was their a spike in suite sales while Barkley was here?  Those suites are sold as long term leases and they are corporate bought.  The corporate sponsorship money was there long before Barkley was on the team and will continue to be there long after all of us and Barkley are gone.

[coggs]

coggs: Agree with it as written, but you didn't say whether you like or dislike the "less and less" part. Bob

Didnt think my opinion about it mattered. 

[Fletch]

Pretty clear that Mara wanted it to work quite desperately with Daniel Jones for a number of reason. One was that whole "we did everything to damage Daniel Jones: line. Which I guess is kind of understandable. mara for all his faults does seem to be a stand-up guy who wants to give someone their due. I mean it just so happens ths team has stunk and, it came time to pay Jones a boat load of money -- I just don't see Mara as a cutthroat wheeler dealer that can say :xxxx happens" I am not paying this guy.

The other part of this is Mara's in general have been conservative and unwilling to change. I remember many years ago, reading in the Cleveland Plain Dealer that Ernie had to drag Wellington kicking and screaming to draft Eli Manning.

It would have been easy to convince Mara to let Barkley walk. The whole rest of the league knows about singing RBs to second contracts. That would have been a big step to go against consensus. Just like letting Jones walk also would have been. There were options out there if you really wanted to. .You could have drafted Levis or Bo Nix. You could have signed Darnold or D Carr or Aaron Rodgers or Kirk Cousins. If you really believed in what you were doing; instead you just went with flow and what the general rules were. Shoen getting to pick the bottom half of a roster is not the same thing as Shoen being allowed to let Jones walk and sign a 150 million dollr free agent without Mara approval. Don't kid yourself.