Week 7 Game Thread: Giants vs. Bengals

[EDjohnst1981]

So if Tommy or the other played tonight they would have won?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Nope. But he's not the most expensive player on the field to put up 7 pts.

[Trench]

So if Tommy or the other played tonight they would have won?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I believe YES 100% - especially since there was TIME to throw

[H-Town G-Fan]

So if Tommy or the other played tonight they would have won?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Who cares? The Giants need a better QB. It's holding them back. So what if an UDFA isn't better than Jones? The fact that it's even arguable is an embarrassment.

[Messiah717]

Even a poor defense knows where Jones is going to go with most of his passes.  How many times short of the sticks on third down?  How many can't wait to get rid of the ball passes not even allowing a receiver to separate?  How many absolute garbage sideline throws because he has no touch? 

[T200]

So if Tommy or the other played tonight they would have won?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Not hating on Jones but I think Tommy would have won this game and it wouldn't have been close... 24-7 Giants.

[MrGap92]

Tommy didn't have a line last year either, he didn't have Wandale a year removed from ACL, who knows?

[kingm56]

Not hating on Jones but I think Tommy would have won this game and it wouldn't have been close... 24-7 Giants.

I do too; it would have taken just average QB play tonight to win...we didn't get that from DJ.  He was objectively bad.

[Trench]

Not hating on Jones but I think Tommy would have won this game and it wouldn't have been close... 24-7 Giants.

I couldn't agree more!

And I'm listening to Daboll as he says each week is different....why do I see other teams able to move the ball consistently each week??

[Trench]

We should have won tonight.

[Messiah717]

We should have won tonight.

Just like Seattle the defense gave them every chance. 

[Ed Vette]

.

[Woody]

I believe YES 100% - especially since there was TIME to throw

Sorry but your dislike of Jones as the only QB that would have lost the game is ?
Your saying that any other QB would have won the game for the Giants?
Ok


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[uconnjack8]

I only count 14 incomplete passes on that chart.  Are some of them just the exact same place?

[kingm56]

Sorry but your dislike of Jones as the only QB that would have lost the game is ?
Your saying that any other QB would have won the game for the Giants?
Ok


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Like or dislike of DJ is irrelevant.  He was objectively bad last night.

[kingm56]

I only count 14 incomplete passes on that chart.  Are some of them just the exact same place?

I assumed the accounted passes were intentionally thrown out-of-bounds, etc.