Using Walter Football comparing this year's QB prospects to last year's

[MightyGiants]

2024

Caleb Williams*, QB, USC
Projected Round (2025): 1.

Jayden Daniels*, QB, LSU
Projected Round (2024): Top-3.

Drake Maye**, QB, North Carolina
Projected Round (2024): Top-5.

J.J. McCarthy*, QB, Michigan
Projected Round (2024): Top-5.

Michael Penix Jr., QB, Washington
Projected Round (2024): 1-2.

Bo Nix, QB, Oregon
Projected Round (2024): 1-2.

2025

Shedeur Sanders*, QB, Colorado
Projected Round (2025): 1.

Quinn Ewers, QB, Texas
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.

Cam Ward, QB, Miami
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.

Jalen Milroe*, QB, Alabama
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.

Carson Beck, QB, Georgia
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.

Drew Allar*, QB, Penn State
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.

Garrett Nussmeier*, QB, LSU
Projected Round (2025): 1-3.


With the exception of Sanders (who does seem to have so issues, similar to Caleb last year) likely being a number one or top 3 QB prospect, the rest are essentially a tick below Bo Nix or Pennix caliber


Barring a QB or two separating themselves from the pack between now and draft day it looks like most of the teams drafting in the top 10 will have plenty of QBs to pick from but most will be considered a reach.

https://walterfootball.com/QBRankings2025.php

https://walterfootball.com/draft2024QB.php

[Ed Vette]

I need to do more work on Cam Ward. I have a friend who really likes him but I've only scouted one game earlier in the year. I like Sanders QB play a lot. He's up there with Daniels and Calib.

[MrGap92]

I need to do more work on Cam Ward. I have a friend who really likes him but I've only scouted one game earlier in the year. I like Sanders QB play a lot. He's up there with Daniels and Calib.

I'd be thrilled with either

I know some are scared of Sanders cause of his dad, but the kid can play and has football in his DNA.

[Jolly Blue Giant]

I think this is a great QB class, but what do I know. I think Carson Beck is going to at the top of the want list, and I wouldn't ignore Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss. There will be quality in the 2nd round as well...like Kyle McCord (SU), or Will Howard (OSU)

[Stringer Bell]

I've come around, a bit, on the idea of throwing a couple of darts the next 2 years in the hopes of getting lucky once.

I don't want to reach in round 1 if we're not 100% sold on someone, but I'm more agreeable to someone like Beck in Round 2 than I was before.

But I think I'd rather take a chance on Rourke from Indiana in Round 4-5 then Beck in Round 2 - especially if we don't get a CB in round 1.

With my son being an Ohio St. fan, I've seen plenty of McCord and Howard and am not a fan of either as NFL prospects.

[katkavage]

Doesn't matter how they are ranked. After passing on one last year they have no choice.

[brownelvis54]

I need to do more work on Cam Ward. I have a friend who really likes him but I've only scouted one game earlier in the year. I like Sanders QB play a lot. He's up there with Daniels and Calib.

I have watched 4 games, and all four left me unimpressed, but I rather have him than any QB on our team. Give me any of the above-mentioned names and get another one in round 3 and have a QB competition in camp. Bring back Taylor or Mariota, Flacco for one year and let the two drafted QBs sit and learn

[files58]

Don't sleep on Brady Cook at Missouri.

[DaveBrown74]

I need to do more work on Cam Ward. I have a friend who really likes him but I've only scouted one game earlier in the year. I like Sanders QB play a lot. He's up there with Daniels and Calib.

I agree about Sanders. I'm quite high on him too.

I'm not high on any other QB at this time.

[AZGiantFan]

Darnold is looking better and better for the Giants.

[MightyGiants]

Doesn't matter how they are ranked. After passing on one last year they have no choice.

I think it's a pretty good rule for the NFL,don't draft a QB you don't love.

A second rule is don't make yourself fall in love.

[Jclayton92]

Don't sleep on Brady Cook at Missouri.

Brady Cook has been anemic this season. Missing wide open passes and reads despite having one of the best Wrs in college football. You could say the same about Carson Beck who has 10 Tds and 11 ints in the last 5 games. Both haven't looked like their 2023 versions.

[Jclayton92]

Darnold is looking better and better for the Giants.

I'd Take Darnold in a heartbeat, add assets this offseason and shoot for a Qb in 2026 unless one of the better Qbs this year falls to the late 1st or early 2nd.

[katkavage]

I think it's a pretty good rule for the NFL,don't draft a QB you don't love.

A second rule is don't make yourself fall in love.

In a perf to world, yeah. But when your coach and GM are desperate, they will have no choice.

[Ed Vette]

I have watched 4 games, and all four left me unimpressed, but I rather have him than any QB on our team. Give me any of the above-mentioned names and get another one in round 3 and have a QB competition in camp. Bring back Taylor or Mariota, Flacco for one year and let the two drafted QBs sit and learn

Him?