Dumpster diving for a new QB in the draft

[MightyGiants]

With the Eagles likely tanking next week, the Giants will be picking 8th or 9th (reward to fans for one of the worst seasons in Giants history).  That means unless Schoen does something stupid and gives away massive draft capital to move up, the following QBs will be available for the Giants to draft.  Which one do you prefer? 

Note-  Because Kyle McCord is trying to stay at Syracuse, I didn't include him on the list despite discussions about him

https://x.com/AlbertBreer/status/1873398644759740698

[spiderblue43]

Nussmeier, I thought, is going back to LSU for another year. Milroe is a boom or bust type. Dart is another choice maybe you consider. I think the Jints will get a pyrrhic win against the Eagles, fall almost out of the top ten and hope and pray they don't let Schoen trade up in desperation.

[Woody]

If a trade is not made for "the guy" the Giants should take a flier on the next level best QB in later rounds...or in round 2 or 3 .....depending on who is sign through free agency....in fact the Giants and most teams should always. grab a QB in every draft unless the position is absolutely set with the Team...
QB's, even the top rated, my or may not work out at the pro level.
Looks like the best option for them at this point is trying to sign a really good FA for the immediate future.. or trading away some draft value if they think the guy is in this upcoming draft.

[MightyGiants]

Nussmeier, I thought, is going back to LSU for another year. Milroe is a boom or bust type. Dart is another choice maybe you consider. I think the Jints will get a pyrrhic win against the Eagles, fall almost out of the top ten and hope and pray they don't let Schoen trade up in desperation.

I included Nussmeier in the poll, you can vote for him

[MrGap92]

This is jumping the gun a bit, but I'd be fine with Milroe or Dart day 2

[MightyGiants]

This is jumping the gun a bit, but I'd be fine with Milroe or Dart day 2

While anything is possible, I would be surprised if Milroe is there day 2

[dasher]

Dillon Gabriel may be the best of the rest.

[Gmo11]

I like Milroe as the best of the rest but I also would prefer that he not start on Day 1 and actually sit a year because he needs to work on his passing a bit.  He'd be better off going to a team with a decent QB there that he can watch and learn from.  The Giants would throw him into the fire whether he was ready or not and likely destroy a promising career. 

[DaveBrown74]

Nothing like sifting through sloppy seconds and sloppy thirds in a bad year for QBs...

[madbadger]

I'd take Kyle McCord in the third round before drafting any of those guys right now. Ewers and Nussmeier have intimated that they will be playing in college next year so you can probably cross them off the list.