If you liked the 2024Giants,

[MightyGiants]

2025:  5-12

Drafting somewhere between 5 and 10 in the 2026 draft and Daboll/Schoen are gone.

Unfortunately that seems like a very likely scenario.  Hopefully Schoen didn't give up too many 2026 picks in his quest for a QB

[Stringer Bell]

The Giants lost to 2 teams with backup QBs (the Eagles had their PS QB technically), 3 if you count the Falcons starting Pennix instead of Cousins

Which, yet again, means absolutely nothing in the context of potential improvement next year with a different roster.

[MightyGiants]

Which, yet again, means absolutely nothing in the context of potential improvement next year with a different roster.

Bobby Skinner took a different approach.  He compared the top 10 players of the Giants with other teams.  The comparisons were not favorable for the Giants and much worse when you factor in the number of top 10 that Schoen and Daboll inherited.

[Stringer Bell]

Bobby Skinner took a different approach.  He compared the top 10 players of the Giants with other teams.  The comparisons were not favorable for the Giants and much worse when you factor in the number of top 10 that Schoen and Daboll inherited.

Yet another irrelevant point on the topic of potential for improvement in 2025.

I'm done. You continue to prove Toomer's point.

[MightyGiants]

Yet another irrelevant point on the topic of potential for improvement in 2025.

I'm done. You continue to prove Toomer's point.

No, I will let you win your argument, you can have that last word.   At for Toomer, do you share his love of trolling our forum?

[Doc16LT56]

Bobby Skinner took a different approach.  He compared the top 10 players of the Giants with other teams.  The comparisons were not favorable for the Giants and much worse when you factor in the number of top 10 that Schoen and Daboll inherited.

Without Dex and AT it's a comically bad top-10. Now we have to worry about AT's long-term health.

[Just_jimmy]

That's such a defeatist take

"Past performance is not indicative of future results."

Piss poor preparation leads to piss poor performance

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

[babywhales]

Guys
Do better
Take it to DM but not here

[LennG]

2025:  5-12

Drafting somewhere between 5 and 10 in the 2026 draft and Daboll/Schoen are gone.

With our schedule for next year that could be generous.

[TDToomer]

Guys
Do better
Take it to DM but not here

So Rich gets the last word after defaming my character and calling me a troll.

[babywhales]

So Rich gets the last word after defaming my character and calling me a troll.

I simply said , collectively do better

When I chimed in after I read the thread

Maybe next time I'll chime in after you make the last comment

You have been around long enough the audience knows the cast

Take it somewhere else via DM

I didn't support one over another, nor did I take sides.

Save that for the DM and all of you do better

[katkavage]

Groundhog Day all over. See you next year this time when the idiot owner has another presser to fire the dynamic duo. Love to see the Vegas odds on that.

[DaveBrown74]

Same management team = same results

If only this had held true following the 2022 season.

[T200]

If only this had held true following the 2022 season.

2022 only counts for certain arguments. This ain't one of them.

[MightyGiants]

2022 only counts for certain arguments. This ain't one of them.

If only this had held true following the 2022 season.

Jeff, I appreciate your point.  I think it's worth remembering that 2022 was achieved mostly on the roster they inherited.