2025 NFL QB market

[MightyGiants]

At just 25 years old, he has already demonstrated the ability to play above average football despite being on some subpar teams. In 2022, he earned MVP and AP votes, an impressive achievement considering he played with limited offensive talent around him. BL: is there another cheap option that can deliver 28 TDs/year? 

2022 (Passing):
2540 YDS / 19 TDs / 11 INTs / 56.3 QBR

2022 (Rushing):
1295 YDS / 9 TDs

-----------------------------------------------
2024 (Passing):
3133 YDS / 14 TDs / 3 INTs / 51.3 QBR

2024 (Rushing):
818 YDS / 14 TDs

**All numbers are 17-game projections.**

Once again, it's important to acknowledge that no one is suggesting he should be the franchise quarterback long-term. However, he is more than capable of helping the Giants remain competitive during a transition year. His presence provides a solid bridge while the team works to establish a more sustainable future.  I don't believe he's magically going to become a +passer...I'm just looking for a guy to get us to 2026, while still being able to make plays and protect the football...

If he exceeds expectations, that's a win—suddenly, the Giants might find themselves with a viable quarterback solution, and you're ahead of schedule. On the other hand, if his performance falls short, that's not the end of the world either. It simply means the Giants will be in a prime position to draft a true franchise quarterback in 2026, giving them a clear path forward. Either way, the team has flexibility...

Matt,

So I take it you are not advocating the Giants drafting a QB in this year's draft.  I can understand that, as it is a weak QB class.    That said, do you think that is what the Giants will do?   

[MrGap92]

I'd rather grab a Raheim Sanders, Tahj Brooks, or Devin Neal later in the draft.

[MightyGiants]

Dan usually has some solid takes on QBs

https://x.com/DanSchneierNFL/status/1877035646386053235

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/robiwittmore/status/1877081110061944887?s=46&t=1vcQIN8GqF5J2oLdxEVEJQ

[Trench]

I place my trust in the Hall of Fame coach of the Steelers.

If he felt at 4-2 he needed a QB change then he knows something and did it for a reason.

Stay FAR away from Fields for this reason. Trust Tomlin judgement.

PS - has any other team that u remember changed QBs with a 4-2 record?...it was fascinating

[EDjohnst1981]

Dan usually has some solid takes on QBs

https://x.com/DanSchneierNFL/status/1877035646386053235

So basically, he's interested in almost everyone that will be available.

Thanks, Dan. That's some insight.

[MightyGiants]

Ceri Dovey💙
@ukgiantsfan1
·
1h
Replying to
@art_stapleton
 
Slightly off topic, but what are your thoughts on Kyle McCord? His winning a shoot-out with Cam gave me a different perspective on his talents. To me, he's a better QB (and prospect) than the Ohio State QB playing in the other semifinal. Potential fallback option for NYG?

[MightyGiants]

Tonight's game pitting PSU and Notre Dame might be worth watching (7:30 EST start).

Notre Dame has one of the best pass defenses in the country. Should Drew Allar light it up against them, his draft stock could skyrocket and cause him to rethink his decision to stay in school.  Allar has all the physical tools of a top QB.  If he declares and has a good post-season draft process, he is the type of prospect that could potentially be in play for NYG at three.

[MightyGiants]

Nick Falato has a high-level understanding of football and QB play.  Here is an article where he explores the possibility of NYG signing Fields


https://www.bigblueview.com/2025/1/9/24339240/new-york-giants-should-pursue-qb-justin-fields-nfl-free-agency-pro-football-focus

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/marcraimondi/status/1877385777711124532

[Bob In PA]

https://x.com/marcraimondi/status/1877385777711124532

Rich: Many may disagree, but it sounds to me like they're fishing for a trade offer. Bob

[MightyGiants]

Rich: Many may disagree, but it sounds to me like they're fishing for a trade offer. Bob

A trade would help the Falcons so a trade would likely involve the FALCONS sending draft picks with Cousins.  The thing is (based on what I could see looking at his contract), Cousins' 2025 salary of $27.5 million is guaranteed. 

Of course, the team that trades for Cousins will suffer that $27.5 million cap hit (even if they spread it out by converting it to a signing bonus).  That's a hefty price for a QB who may be too old to be starter.

[PSUBeirut]

Tonight's game pitting PSU and Notre Dame might be worth watching (7:30 EST start).

Notre Dame has one of the best pass defenses in the country. Should Drew Allar light it up against them, his draft stock could skyrocket and cause him to rethink his decision to stay in school.  Allar has all the physical tools of a top QB.  If he declares and has a good post-season draft process, he is the type of prospect that could potentially be in play for NYG at three.

Highly doubt this happens.  ND's secondary is very good and our WRs...not so much.  And Allar has all the physical tools but just hasn't put them together yet  (I'm hopeful it's because we need significantly upgraded talent at WR).
Fully expect the PSU offense to run directly through our RB duo and Tyler Warren- against an injured front 7.  Anything different would be coaching malpractice.  LET'S GO PSU!!!!

[MightyGiants]

Highly doubt this happens.  ND's secondary is very good and our WRs...not so much.  And Allar has all the physical tools but just hasn't put them together yet  (I'm hopeful it's because we need significantly upgraded talent at WR).
Fully expect the PSU offense to run directly through our RB duo and Tyler Warren- against an injured front 7.  Anything different would be coaching malpractice.  LET'S GO PSU!!!!

Thank you for raining on my parade 

Seriously, I am just hoping one of the second-tier QBs does enough to justify being drafted with the third pick.   While I am not opposed to drafting a QB via trade back to the bottom or round one or the top of round two, the problem is when you go that route there is no assurance of getting your man

[EDjohnst1981]

A trade would help the Falcons so a trade would likely involve the FALCONS sending draft picks with Cousins.  The thing is (based on what I could see looking at his contract), Cousins' 2025 salary of $27.5 million is guaranteed. 

Of course, the team that trades for Cousins will suffer that $27.5 million cap hit (even if they spread it out by converting it to a signing bonus).  That's a hefty price for a QB who may be too old to be starter.

Would be shocked if anyone traded even a 7th for him with that cap hit. But stranger things have happened.