What coaches say about Sanders

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/CoryRAanalytics/status/1908204823796752401

[madbadger]

Just read that Travis Hunter didn't run a 40 at his pro day. That is a gigantic red flag for me. If he was a legit 4.4 guy he'd run it. He plays two positions where speed is at a premium. After watch Neal struggle with speed rushes Schoen shouldn't waste a high draft pick on a guy too scared to put a time on paper. Hard pass for me.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/DMRussini/status/1908236404947300637

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/DMRussini/status/1908236404947300637

By my calculation, that was an 80-yard pass

[Uncle Mickey]

I am pretty much convinced Giants will NOT be taking Sanders at 3.

However a trade back up in round 1 should he slide is possible.

[Ed Vette]

[Uncle Mickey]

Forgetting Sanders and Ward for a minute..... what other QB in this draft tickles your fancy

If any?

I am not a Milton fan at all, I see no real strong QB skill but just a guy you can gimmick with. This guy is nowhere near a Lamar Jackson or Jayden Daniels type. He is all run, no pass.

WIll Howard intrigues me and right or wrong, fits the Giants rigid prototype: 6'4 or taller, 225 or more, strong arm, decent character, not flamboyant.

I like Tyler SHough's tape a lot but does the broken bone  and age stuff scare you?

McCord ...decision amking was horrible but change of scenery did him good. Some good traits....

Dart ....is he more fools good like Matt Corral in that one read Kiffin offense or is he more than a one read guy who just happened to play in a one read offense. Lot of qualities to like with him if in fact hecan go through progressions

[MightyGiants]

I will say, that I am underwhelmed when I hear him speak

[Jclayton92]

Forgetting Sanders and Ward for a minute..... what other QB in this draft tickles your fancy

If any?

I am not a Milton fan at all, I see no real strong QB skill but just a guy you can gimmick with. This guy is nowhere near a Lamar Jackson or Jayden Daniels type. He is all run, no pass.

WIll Howard intrigues me and right or wrong, fits the Giants rigid prototype: 6'4 or taller, 225 or more, strong arm, decent character, not flamboyant.

I like Tyler SHough's tape a lot but does the broken bone  and age stuff scare you?

McCord ...decision amking was horrible but change of scenery did him good. Some good traits....

Dart ....is he more fools good like Matt Corral in that one read Kiffin offense or is he more than a one read guy who just happened to play in a one read offense. Lot of qualities to like with him if in fact hecan go through progressions

You're helmet scouting Dart. There is no comparison between him and Matt Corral. Corral didn't fail because he wasn't good, the kid had a mental breakdown which had nothing to do with how he throws a ball. People did the same thing when CJ Stroud came out, they helmet scouted him and assumed he was going to be Dewayne Haskins 2.0 because they went to the same school even though they were two completely different players. Also it isn't a 1 read offense, that's another misconception as Dart does go through progressions.

[Uncle Mickey]

You're helmet scouting Dart. There is no comparison between him and Matt Corral. Corral didn't fail because he wasn't good, the kid had a mental breakdown which had nothing to do with how he throws a ball. People did the same thing when CJ Stroud came out, they helmet scouted him and assumed he was going to be Dewayne Haskins 2.0 because they went to the same school even though they were two completely different players. Also it isn't a 1 read offense, that's another misconception as Dart does go through progressions.

Not at all. If you read what I said, I posed it as an either/or scenario with no true judgement or opinion either way while stating that if he is more than a one read type QB there are a lot of qualities to like with him.

However, I do believe the Kiffin offense while not exclusively 1 read (almost no offense is ) it does heavily rely on less reads and more straightforward concepts that are usually on average much more nuanced in the NFL. So that absolutely is a factor to consider in the evaluation.