Bobby Skinner does the history of each of the Giants draft pick positions

[MightyGiants]

He has gone as deep as 154, so I will post his list.  I threw one of the Tweets so you can give him a follow.

Giants have the 3rd pick. Recent history of pick #3

2024: Drake Maye
2023: Will Anderson Jr
2022: Derek Stingley
2021: Trey Lance
2020: Jeff Okudah
2019: Quinnen Williams
2018: Sam Darnold
2017: Solomon Thomas
2016: Joey Bosa
2015: Dante Fowler
2014: Blake Bortles


Giants have the 34th pick. Recent history of pick #34

2024: WR Ladd McConkey
2023: TE Sam LaPorta
2022: WR Christian Watson
2021: WR Elijah Moore
2020: WR Michael Pittman Jr
2019: CB Rock Ya-Sin
2018: OG Will Hernandez
2017: OT Cam Robinson
2016: LB Jaylon Smith
2015: OT Donovan Smith


Giants have the 65th pick. Recent history of pick #65

2024: WR Malachi Corley
2023: OL Tyler Steen
2022: OL Luke Fortner
2021: S Andre Cisco
2020: LB Logan Wilson
2019: DL Zach Allen
2018: OL Brandon Parker
2017: DL Larry Ogunjobi
2016: DE Carl Nassib
2015: CB D'Joun Smith


Giants have the 99th pick. Recent history of pick #99

2024: S Kam Kinchens
2023: K Jake Moody
2022: WR David Bell
2021: DB Nahshon Wright
2020: OT Matt Peart
2019: S Mike Edwards
2018: CB Isaac Yiadom
2017: CB Rasul Douglas
2016: LB Joe Schobert
2015: LB Paul Dawson



Giants have the 105th pick. Recent history of pick #105

2024: DL Justin Eboigbe
2023: CB Kelee Ringo
2022: WR Danny Gray
2021: LB Baron Browning
2020: TE Adam Trautman
2019: S CJ Gardner-Johnson
2018: WR Antonio Callaway
2017: RB James Conner
2016: OL Parker Ehinger
2015: WR Jamison Crowder


Giants have the 154th pick. Recent history of pick #154

2024: DE Brennan Jackson
2023: C Olu Oluwatimi
2022: RB Snoop Conner
2021: S Michael Carter
2020: DL Jason Strowbridge
2019: RB Jordan Scarlett
2018: CB Siran Neal
2017: TE Jeremy Sprinkle
2016: WR Jordan Payton
2015: DT Tyeler Davison


https://x.com/BobbySkinner_/status/1912125000964063393

[Philosophers]

I never understand this point.  So what if Ladd McConkey was picked.  Another team may have picked a better or worse player.  Means nothing.  We know valuable players exist around those picks.  The issue is picking the right one.

[MightyGiants]

I never understand this point.  So what if Ladd McConkey was picked.  Another team may have picked a better or worse player.  Means nothing.  We know valuable players exist around those picks.  The issue is picking the right one.

I don't fully understand your point.  The purpose of the exercise is to give a sense of the caliber of player that should be available to NYG at each pick.

[Philosophers]

Rich - it's only the caliber of player picked not who was available.  The pick could have been a bust but two future All Pros were sitting behind who were not selected.

[bamagiantfan]

https://x.com/BobbySkinner_/status/1912125000964063393

If you want to draft a QB with the third overall pick, that list should scare the hell out of you.

[MightyGiants]

Giants have the 219th pick. Recent history of pick #219

2024: CB Daequan Hardy
2023: WR Antoine Green
2022: LB Chance Campbell
2021: WR Seth Williams
2020: S Geno Stone
2019: OL Derwin Gray
2018: QB Danny Etling
2017: WR Stacy Coley
2016: S Will Parks
2015: LB Hayes Pullard

[MightyGiants]

Rich - it's only the caliber of player picked not who was available.  The pick could have been a bust but two future All Pros were sitting behind who were not selected.

I think I get your point, but the reality is that no one is going to be perfect at picking.  So I think it's more accurate to see who was actually picked at a given spot, what players remained on the board at that point because hindsight is 20/20

[MightyGiants]

Giants have the 246th pick. Recent history of pick #246

2024: TE Devin Culp
2023: CB Dj Ivey
2022: OL Dawson Deaton
2021: DL Shaka Toney
2020: RB Malcom Perry
2019: C Javon Patterson
2018: DT Joshua Frazier
2017: DT Jordan Carrell
2016: LB Tyler Matakevich
2015: TE Geoff Swaim

[ralphpal1]

The first round and 3rd pick of the draft
Some.are awesome
Some weren't

[kartanoman]

I don't fully understand your point.  The purpose of the exercise is to give a sense of the caliber of player that should be available to NYG at each pick.

That's a generally fair point, Rich @MightyGiants  . Of course, that's relative to the depth of strength and weakness by position across the draft. If we preface each year/round by its relative strengths/weaknesses by position, maybe it conveys a deeper understanding when looking at each team and its respective record and needs vs. wants analysis for a given year.

But, from a general feel, I get the picture here and it serves its purpose just fine.

Peace!

[DaveBrown74]

I think the point of the tweet is simply to give viewers an idea of how that point in the draft has played out over a number of years. As Rich said it's to give an idea of the types of players available at each point in the draft. Every draft is different obviously. I don't think the intent is to make some sort of prediction of how the pick will turn out for the Giants. More just to illustrate what the menu might roughly look like each team they're on the clock. I think it's a reasonably useful enough tweet given all the clickbait garbage that's out there right now.