Big Blue Huddle

To be totally honest, I haven't seen him play at all. Garbage time hi-lights
Stuff. But I respect those that have.

One thing off the top..he moves much better on the run.

But that's like co.paring him to Herman Munster..darn..darn.darn..

Be careful of the highlight reels. Arch has a way to go before he can be considered a top QB. The Defense they faced was extremely weak and the RR system is a well Designed Offense. It was like TX was playing the Paramus HS football team. He missed hot reads and checkdowns and I haven't even finished watching the tape. He's got talent and he's a chip off the old grandpa.

Quote from: Ed Vette on September 18, 2024, 02:20:23 PMBe careful of the highlight reels. Arch has a way to go before he can be considered a top QB. The Defense they faced was extremely weak and the RR system is a well Designed Offense. It was like TX was playing the Paramus HS football team. He missed hot reads and checkdowns and I haven't even finished watching the tape. He's got talent and he's a chip off the old grandpa.

Couldn't agree more, great post.

Every QB at any point is growing in their career.  How do traits look at his stage?  I'd say pretty darn good.  Work to go?  Yes.  On a runway to success?  Yes also.

If there is a year to win this is it. Next year we are tanking. Eli and Payten guiding Arch to the Giants. If the Giants aren't the worst they need the highest pick after that to trade.

Arch will be good and a top draft pick. However we need a QB in the 2025 draft, and I think there are a number of good QBs in this draft. Ewers, Ward, Dart, Beck, NUssmeier, and possible Milroe (to name a few).

Would you trade Daniel Jones plus an additional first round pick for the guaranteed rights to Arch Manning after the 2025 Texas season right now?

Quote from: DaveBrown74 on September 19, 2024, 07:41:22 PMWould you trade Daniel Jones plus an additional number one pick for the guaranteed rights to Arch Manning after the 2025 Texas season right now?

In a nanosecond