Big Blue Huddle

https://x.com/Marcus_Mosher/status/1882428330936599021

Feels like there's gonna be some wild differences of opinion on Sanders. Kiper being the high man on both QBs is interesting as well. Also, more of a critique of the calculation but, Membou being 21 based on appearing on one list seems ridiculous. Scouts Inc. has him at 129 and he's not in Brugler's top 50 but gets weighted entirely based on that 21.

Quote from: jgrangers2 on January 23, 2025, 12:23:39 PMFeels like there's gonna be some wild differences of opinion on Sanders. Kiper being the high man on both QBs is interesting as well. Also, more of a critique of the calculation but, Membou being 21 based on appearing on one list seems ridiculous. Scouts Inc. has him at 129 and he's not in Brugler's top 50 but gets weighted entirely based on that 21.

Yeah, if I was doing the list I would give any player not on one of the "experts" lists a max ranking.  In other words, if they don't appear on Bugler's top 50, they should be given a 51 for purposes of creating the master list.

So the top QB is 10th?

I think we should do a BBH top 75. Have it a consensus big board, there are 91 days until the draft. The next 75 days we do a prospect a day from 1 to 75. We serve two purposes doing this, we educate people who don't have the time like some of us draft diehards, we have a big board to fall back on to quickly get info about a certain prospect we might be debating in another thread, and then during the draft we have something to go by, and it'll be fun to see how we match up with the broader audience.

I know Dan and I do our own top 100 and from us talking ours are almost identical but it'd be fun to have a recurring thing daily were we decide on the prospect at #1 or #30. Plus it'll give new, fresh, daily content. Just have a pin thread and then it can be something we do yearly that hopefully can helps the fan base.

Quote from: uconnjack8 on January 23, 2025, 12:32:50 PMSo the top QB is 10th?

I found another good consensus big board here

https://jacklich10.com/bigboard/nfl/

Bonus, they still have 2024 for comparison


2024

Caleb- 2nd
Maye- 6th
Daniels- 10th
JJ- 27th
Nix- 35th
Penix- 36th
Rattler- 86th

Here is the link to the consensus big boards

https://jacklich10.com/bigboard/nfl/


2025

Sanders- 9
Ward- 10
Milroe- 45
Ewers- 69
Dart- 89

Quote from: Jclayton92 on January 23, 2025, 12:56:03 PMI think we should do a BBH top 75. Have it a consensus big board, there are 91 days until the draft. The next 75 days we do a prospect a day from 1 to 75. We serve two purposes doing this, we educate people who don't have the time like some of us draft diehards, we have a big board to fall back on to quickly get info about a certain prospect we might be debating in another thread, and then during the draft we have something to go by, and it'll be fun to see how we match up with the broader audience.

I know Dan and I do our own top 100 and from us talking ours are almost identical but it'd be fun to have a recurring thing daily were we decide on the prospect at #1 or #30. Plus it'll give new, fresh, daily content. Just have a pin thread and then it can be something we do yearly that hopefully can helps the fan base.

Go for it

Quote from: MightyGiants on January 23, 2025, 01:41:58 PMGo for it

Trying to figure out the best way to have a singular pinned thread where people can vote between a handful of prospects each day to be for example #1 overall and then whoever gets voted on we can list pros, cons, and scouting report. I just don't know that its possible to do a daily vote on one thread that'll disappear daily so we can do the next day. And if we can't do that, what is the best way to do a big board where we can do a daily prospect with everyone's input so it's not just my Top 75, but the forums top 50-75.

If anyone has any ideas or wants to be involved in helping with the big board including prospect scouting reports for the forum feel free to DM me.

Quote from: Jclayton92 on January 23, 2025, 09:18:51 PMTrying to figure out the best way to have a singular pinned thread where people can vote between a handful of prospects each day to be for example #1 overall and then whoever gets voted on we can list pros, cons, and scouting report. I just don't know that its possible to do a daily vote on one thread that'll disappear daily so we can do the next day. And if we can't do that, what is the best way to do a big board where we can do a daily prospect with everyone's input so it's not just my Top 75, but the forums top 50-75.

If anyone has any ideas or wants to be involved in helping with the big board including prospect scouting reports for the forum feel free to DM me.

Jesse,

This is a challenging one.  I will give it some thought, I will do anything I can to make this happen though.