2025 NFL QB market

[Giantleap56]

Matt,

I wasn't interested in Fields last season, but I am this season (using the "beggers can't be choosers" logic.  Who do you think would be a realistic alternative to Fields that would give Schoen and Daboll a chance to put up a respectable record?

I'll take Fields only if Mike Tomlinson comes along. Daboll will make him look like trash.

[MightyGiants]

I'll take Fields only if Mike Tomlinson comes along. Daboll will make him look like trash.

I won't disagree, but as one anonymous Giants player said, "It's like your only option is to blindly trust,"

At this point, there is nothing I can do. The decisions have been made, and all that I have left is to support the team and hope for the best.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/PeteThamel/status/1877773682698817972

[MightyGiants]

McCord officially declares for the draft

[kingm56]

I'll take Fields only if Mike Tomlinson comes along. Daboll will make him look like trash.

Daboll made the Vikings' current third-string quarterback look serviceable in 2022, which was impressive in my opinion. Also, Fields' best season was 2022, during which he actually received MVP and AP votes. Did the great Matt Eberflus make him look serviceable? It seems like you and the other fans who predicted DJ would become a top-10 QB are now bashing Daboll for failing to make your predictions come true.  Daboll is not responsible for making DJ look like trash; he looked like trash because he was an average QB...

[coggs]

Justin Fields is not going to be talked about as a future all pro any time soon.

But two important areas he has over DJ:

He keeps his eyes up longer than DJ while scrambling away from pressure.

He's unafraid to throw the ball downfield.

He could develop into a starter BONUS! Or MORE LIKELY he's a decent bridge until we get the franchise QB.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Eli Manning was never all-pro and didnt exactly look like a world-beater his first few seasons.

[Trench]

Eli Manning was never all-pro and didnt exactly look like a world-beater his first few seasons.

2x Super Bowl MVP. Perhaps we should keep Eli out of this Fields conversation

[MightyGiants]

Another potential competitor in the QB market could be the Steelers.  Will the Steelers be satisfied going back in 2025 with Russel Wilson?

[MightyGiants]

It's worth listing all the teams in the market for a franchise QB

Jets
Steelers
Browns
Titans
POTENTIALLY the Colts
Raiders
Giants
Saints
POTENTIALLY the Rams

[MightyGiants]

2025 free agent QBs

[zbeaster]

QB prospects with more football

College Playoffs

Howard OSU, Ewers Texas, Allar PSU (some rumors he might change his mind about entering the draft), and Leonard ND


Senior Bowl


Jaxson DartQB | Mississippi


Will HowardQB | Ohio State


Dillon GabrielQB | Oregon


Riley LeonardQB | Notre Dame


Tyler ShoughQB | Louisville

Shrine Bowl

Shedeur Sanders, Colorado
Kyle McCord, Syracuse
Tyler Shough, Louisville
Kurtis Rourke, Indiana

Who do you like most of the Senior Bowl guys?

[MightyGiants]

Who do you like most of the Senior Bowl guys?

Welcome 

I am eager to see Dart in a more traditional QB role.

Beyond that, I am hoping that maybe Howard, Gabriel, or Leonard really shine and show some potential to be a franchise QB (it's a long shot, and obviously you need to consider more than just the Senior Bowl).

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/rydunleavy/status/1878904437072437364

[Jclayton92]

Miami paid 2 million for a 1 year rental of a broken qb in Beck. That's how ridiculous the NIL market is right now. Also Beck making his decision based on his girlfriend might be alarming to some.

[MightyGiants]

In terms of Sanders and Ward, my feeling is this:

The Giants draft 3rd in what appears to be a two QB market and both teams ahead of them desperately (like the Giants) need a QB.   I doubt either would trade with the Giants unless they have serious doubts about the abilities of Ward and/or Sanders.   Neither will fall unless the Titans or Browns have serious doubts about the pair.

So, beyond the usual crapshoot that comes with drafting a QB, you would be drafting (3rd overall) a QB another team felt wasn't good enough.  I would think that another team assessed and passed on the prospect would lower the chances of success should the Giants pick either of them.