Giants will have one QB on the roster some time this week

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/art_stapleton/status/1897650239944704393

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/art_stapleton/status/1897674417657741408

[Painter]

Good Gosh! When you're 3-5 in 12 games/ 8 starts and have an average QBR of 25, you're not far from being called, Tommy DeFeato. I suppose it's just cheap and easier to not Cut&let him when there are far harder decisions to be made.

Cheers!

[MrGap92]

Good Gosh! When you're 3-5 in 12 games/ 8 starts and have an average QBR of 25, you're not far from being called, Tommy DeFeato. I suppose it's just cheap and easier to not Cut&let him when there are far harder decisions to be made.

Cheers!

  

[MightyGiants]

Good Gosh! When you're 3-5 in 12 games/ 8 starts and have an average QBR of 25, you're not far from being called, Tommy DeFeato. I suppose it's just cheap and easier to not Cut&let him when there are far harder decisions to be made.

Cheers!

I would love to see the Giants double dip at QB this draft and replace him.   Let's face it, his ceiling is low-end QB 3.  He lacks the tools to be anything else.   If you are going to have a 3rd QB, either draft one or take a flyer on a player talented enough to have once been a round one QB like Trey Lance or Zach Wilson

[madbadger]

I would love to see the Giants double dip at QB this draft and replace him.   Let's face it, his ceiling is low-end QB 3.  He lacks the tools to be anything else.   If you are going to have a 3rd QB, either draft one or take a flyer on a player talented enough to have once been a round one QB like Trey Lance or Zach Wilson

Some precedent for doing that. The Cowboys drafted Troy Aikman first overall and then used the following years first round draft pick to draft Steve Walsh in the supplemental draft.

[MrGap92]

No guarantee, so he may very well not even be with the team after all is said and done.

[Philosophers]

Good Gosh! When you're 3-5 in 12 games/ 8 starts and have an average QBR of 25, you're not far from being called, Tommy DeFeato. I suppose it's just cheap and easier to not Cut&let him when there are far harder decisions to be made.

Cheers!

Larry - the fact we on this board discuss DeVito as much as we do tells us about the lack of talent and depth of fall.

[Painter]

Larry - the fact we on this board discuss DeVito as much as we do tells us about the lack of talent and depth of fall.

As regards DeVito, I take your point, Joseph. But what most Giants fans seem to overlook, fail to appreciate is that what we have been experiencing during this latest decade plus is little more than another chapter in the Giants long losing history, one spanning the now 60+ years of the Super Bowl era.

Except for a couple of otherwise brief episodes of Lombardi joy, the franchise history, of the Mara Nation, is that of a loser. And that good sir is contrary to what does, and certainly should, define Giants fan; faithful, always hopeful, beaten but never bowed. One who confronts the neigh sayers, the negative odds-makers with optimism, or at least with a realism not strangled by pessimism, dare I say masochism.

Cheers!

[andrew_nyGiants]

I could see another UDFA bump DeVito off the roster by HOF weekend.

[MightyGiants]

https://x.com/bigblueview/status/1898431041364476309?s=61&t=RhLqKLKssFU2uI0Nr0nfxQ

[spiderblue43]

This era of Giants football reminds me of former VP Spiro Agnew classic quote to paraphrase "the negative nabobs of negativism" we have to live with.

Or Bush cabinet head Donald Rumsfeld's poetic "there are known knows..and unknown unknowns".

A slog of football failure.