News:

Moderation Team: Vette, babywhales, Bob In PA, gregf, bighitterdalama, beaugestus, T200

Owner: MightyGiants

Link To Live Chat

Mastodon

Main Menu

My worry with Carter being BPA at 3...

Started by UKGiantsFan, March 26, 2025, 03:56:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Jclayton92

I'd play Carter at MLB on 1st and 2nd down, then pass rusher on 3rd down with Lawrence, Golson, Burns, Thibs, Okereke, Carter, and Dimukeje on the field on

Chatman, Lawrence, Golson
Thibs, Carter, Okereke, Burns

Then

Burns, Lawrence, Golson, Thibs
Carter, okereke, Dimukeje

I think you can move Carter all over the field and he'll be elite. Plus if you don't Resign Thibodeaux then you have Carter, or if you don't Resign Okereke then you have Carter.


With Hunter I play him at WR year 1 because the most immediate impact he can make this coming year is at Wr. With all the the assests teams will throw at Nabors now knowing that we actually have Qbs that excel going deep will leave Hunter one 1⃣ one with teams number 2 or 3 CB. The ome thing I got from the Sanders tape I watched is that Hunter is easily the best Wr in this class and it's not being talked about enough how elite he is at the position. I would also have him learn CB in the event that we have an injury and if you do lose Banks or he doesn't continue to develop. Either way with Hunter, you immediately have one the top 5 to 10 CB groups or Wr groups going into next year.

Outside AJ Brown/Smith, and Higgins/Chase who would have a better 2 deep, or even 4 deep at Wr? I'd take Nabors/Hunter over Metcalf/Pickens, Nacua/Adams, Evans/Godwin, St Brown/Williamson, Mclaurin/Deebo. Our 4 deep of Nabors, Hunter, Wandale, Slayton could go up against any 4 deep in the NFL.

Especially when you factor in age, contract etc.

Likewise on defense, we immediately have the best young secondary in the league.
Adebo, Holland 25
Banks Nubin, Phillips 23
Hunter 21

Even if you put Carter back into the discussion, and we take him, then who I'm the NFL would have a better front 7 than us? Okereke, and Lawrence are a year removed from being top 2 at their position then you add Golson who I think will blow up with us next to dex, and then Thibs, Burns, Carter, and Dimukeje.

Either way with these two guys we win, and then have 4 more picks in the top 105 to add to the team. I know a lot of people have been down on the team and the roster but we have really young, good talent, and if we ace this draft then we could legitimately be a Qb away.

Say ontop of Carter or Hunter, we add a DT, RG, RB, (Wr or Edge depending on who we take at 3), a developmental tackle, and TE. Say we hit on all of them, then in my eyes we have the best YOUNG team in the NFL, and would just be missing a QB.

All that to say that things could be changing really quickly around here, and for all the xxxx Schoen gets, if we hit this draft out of the park then I'm more excited for this team than I have been in a decade.

Bob In PA

Quote from: Jclayton92 on March 26, 2025, 10:39:43 PMI'd play Carter at MLB on 1st and 2nd down, then pass rusher on 3rd down with Lawrence, Golson, Burns, Thibs, Okereke, Carter, and Dimukeje on the field on

Chatman, Lawrence, Golson
Thibs, Carter, Okereke, Burns

Then

Burns, Lawrence, Golson, Thibs
Carter, okereke, Dimukeje

I think you can move Carter all over the field and he'll be elite. Plus if you don't Resign Thibodeaux then you have Carter, or if you don't Resign Okereke then you have Carter.

J: That plan also works. Although Carter and Micah Parson are very different players, the thing they have most in common is that they are both very comfortable starting from multiple defensive positions. Bob
If Jeff Hostetler could do it, Daniel Jones can do it !!!

killarich

If we were to take Carter, how good is he at coverage ? Is it possible he can start in McFadden's spot ?  Can he play with his hand in the ground at all ?

Jclayton92

Quote from: killarich on March 27, 2025, 05:25:56 AMIf we were to take Carter, how good is he at coverage ? Is it possible he can start in McFadden's spot ?  Can he play with his hand in the ground at all ?
Both, he's played Mike, outside linebacker, and Edge in college excelling at all positions. He took 750 snaps off tackle, and a 1,000 at off ball linebacker in college.