A look back at the accuracy of draft pundits

[MightyGiants]

But how accurate are the pundits one month out? It's a question we started asking ourselves, and there's only one way to find out: by reviewing their work. So here's a look at what the seven services we review (Pro Football Network, PFF, CBS' Chris Trapasso, The Draft Scout, ESPN, The Athletic's Dane Brugler and Walter Football) said about the last two draft classes.
2023 DRAFT

• Top five predicted picks: CJ Stroud, QB, Ohio State; Bryce Young, QB, Alabama; Will Anderson, DE, Alabama; Anthony Richardson, QB, Florida; and Tyree Wilson, DE, Texas Tech.
• Actual top five picks: Young, Stroud, Anderson, Richardson, then Illinois DC Devon Witherspoon to the Seahawks. Witherspoon's average draft slot (ADS) was 14.4.
• Biggest misses: All seven services had Kentucky QB Will Levis going in the first round, with an average draft slot of 7.85. Levis wound up going 2/33 to the Titans. Also, all seven services had Penn State DC Joey Porter Jr. going in the first round (ADS 19.0), but he slid to the first pick of the second round.
• Other surprises: Texas OH Bijan Robinson went 1/8 to the Falcons despite an ADS of 17.1, though, in fairness, we've learned the Falcons often go against the grain. Also, Georgia OB Nolan Smith went 1/30 to the Eagles despite an ADS of 17.5.
• Kudos: Only Trapasso had Mississippi State DC Emmanuel Forbes going in the first round a month before the draft; he had Forbes at 1/24 (he went 1/16 to the Commanders). Also, only two services (PFF and The Draft Scout's Matt Miller) had Kansas St. DE Felix Anudike-Uzomah in the first round, and both nailed his draft slot (31). Further hats off to PFF for sticking with the prediction and nailing the pick a week before the draft (Miller had abandoned Anudike-Uzomah as a Day 1 selection by then).

2024 DRAFT

• Top five predicted picks: USC QB Caleb Williams; LSU QB Jayden Daniels; North Carolina QB Drake Maye; Ohio State WO Marvin Harrison Jr.; and Michigan QB J.J. McCarthy.
• Actual top five picks: Williams, Daniels, Maye, Harrison and Notre Dame OT Joe Alt.
• Biggest misses: All 22 players predicted to go in Round 1 actually did, so congratulations are in order. On the other hand, not one service, over the course of seven different mocks lasting from June until the week before the draft, ever identified Florida WO Ricky Pearsall (1/31, 49ers) as a first-rounder. Also worth noting: a week before the draft, no one saw South Carolina WO Xavier Legette (1/32, Panthers) as a first-rounder.
• Other surprises: Things were a little bumpy for Pro Football Network, which was the only service to leave Texas DT Byron Murphy (1/16, Seahawks) off its first-round mock. Similarly, Walter Football was the only site to overlook Duke OT Graham Barton (1/26, Bucs) and CBS' Trapasso was the only one who snubbed Oklahoma OT Tyler Guyton (1/29, Cowboys).
• Kudos: ESPN's Matt Miller (12) and Walter Football (13) were the only two services that saw Oregon QB Bo Nix (1/12, Broncos) as a Day 1 pick. Miller's website, The Draft Scout, stuck with the prediction on Nix a week before the draft and nailed it, as did Walter Football (Trapasso had him at 15 a week before the draft; no other services saw him as a Day 1 selection). Also, only Pro Football Network (13) and Brugler (21) had Washington QB Michael Penix as a first-rounder; he went 1/8 to the Falcons.

https://succeedinfootball.com/2025/03/28/a-look-back-at-how-the-pundits-viewed-the-23-and-24-drafts/

[Bob In PA]

Even blind pigs occasionally find a few acorns. lol

Seriously, I believe the "science" of experts predicting the first round has improved notably over my lifetime.

Nice post, but IMO it's only of note to us because it shows there's reason to hope a guy or two tagged for the 1st round might fall to day two. Holding Pick 34, we can easily (and cheaply) trade up to Pick 33 (if necessary) to ensure getting someone whom the Giants strongly believe should not have fallen.

Bob